The best golf courses in New Jersey
New Jersey boasts the No. 1 course in the nation—if not the world—though it’s closer to Philadelphia than most of New Jersey. Pine Valley has earned the top spot in every edition of our America’s 100 Greatest rankings except four times—when it was second each time. Of course, that’s just the beginning of the golf conversation with New Jersey as nine layouts in the Garden State are ranked among our top 200.
Some of the best designs by the game’s classic architects—A.W. Tillinghast lived for much of his life in New Jersey and gave us both courses at Baltusrol, a unique masterpiece at Somerset Hills and a fabulous 27-hole facility at Ridgewood Country Club. Donald Ross gems can be found throughout the state, including at Plainfield Country Club and Mountain Ridge Country Club, plus there are entries from Seth Raynor (including Morris County Golf Club, which just discovered that C.B. Macdonald worked on the design), Charles Banks (whose work at Essex County Country Club has just been restored by Gil Hanse) and Walter Travis (whose Hollywood Golf Club continues to move up in our rankings).
The modern marvels that can be equal parts awe-inspiring and polarizing. Liberty National just dropped out of our top 200 for the first time since its debut. Its neighbor, Bayonne, leapfrogged Tom Fazio’s Galloway National by a few decimal points. Both of Fazio’s Trump courses (Pine Hill and Bedminster-Old) dropped in this list. And the new Union League National in Cape May Court House, a high-budget redo of the old Sand Barrens Golf Course, inched its way up our Best Courses in New Jersey list, as it and Mountain Ridge and Essex County remain on the cusp of making our top 200.
More From Golf Digest
Below you'll find our 2025-'26 ranking of the Best Golf Courses in New Jersey.
Scroll on for the complete list of the best courses in New Jersey. Be sure to click through to each individual course page for bonus photography and reviews from our course panelists. We also encourage you to leave your own ratings … so you can make your case for (or against) any course that you've played.
1 / 5
Courtesy of the club
2 / 5
Courtesy of the club
3 / 5
Courtesy of the club
4 / 5
Courtesy of the club
5 / 5
Courtesy of the club
Previous rank: NR
Watchung Valley Golf Club’s extensive restoration plan by George Waters brought to life an unbuilt Seth Raynor routing, constructed after his death by Plainfield Country Club’s Marty O’Laughlin, revealing the rolling topography and bold features on the site of this old dairy farm. Hundreds of trees were cleared out over the past 10 years to bring the club back to its roots as one of New Jersey’s most prideful clubs. A number of Raynor’s templates can be found here, particularly on the back nine, including the 11th (Eden), a standout par-4 12th (Bottle), a rare par-3 punchbowl 13th and the prize-dogleg 16th. An emphasis on walking and firm-and-fast conditions, plus a new short course with six greens dubbed the Merry-Go-Round, designed by Blake Conant (the club’s current consulting architect), gives this character-filled hidden gem a great sense of place—and continues to bring more notoriety to the club.
1 / 3
2 / 3
3 / 3
Previous rank: 25
Any fan of the Mac/Raynor/Banks style of architecture must go see Forsgate Country Club’s Banks course, which features an outstanding quartet of par 3s, including the bold and dramatic Biarritz 17th. Though Forsgate often struggles in our conditioning category, its landforms and deep bunkering are worth studying and experiencing—and make it deserving of its place among New Jersey’s best courses.
1 / 8
Evan Schiller
2 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
3 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
4 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
5 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
6 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
7 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
8 / 8
Evan Schiller/evanschillerphotography.com
Previous rank: 23
Hackensack is an incredibly enjoyable Charles Banks design that incorporates several template holes as well as original ones to create a great golf course in North Jersey. The course includes a Redan (12th), Biarritz (3rd) and one of the best punchbowls in Banks’ portfolio at the 16th. Over the past few years, the club has embarked on a massive renovation overseen by Steve Weisser and Rees Jones with the goal of restoring most of the course and adding a few new ones, like the 150-yard fairway bunker at the 11th, which sits nearly eight feet deep. Additionally, the club has removed many trees, opening up the property and allowing golfers to see much more of the property.
1 / 6
LC Lambrecht
2 / 6
LC Lambrecht
3 / 6
LC Lambrecht
4 / 6
LC Lambrecht
5 / 6
LC Lambrecht
6 / 6
Previous rank: 20
Atlantic City Country Club is now private, but if you're headed to AC for a golf trip, do your best to try to get on. The par-70, 6,577-yard course dates to 1897 but has been updated several times, including in 1999 by architect Tom Doak. He did his best to restore many original features, including firm, undulating greens and tall, native grasses that frame bunkers and fairways. Willie Park Jr., the British Open champion in 1887 and 1889, is often credited as the primary designer, though at least four others are responsible for this classic layout. ACCC is routed along marshland and back bays and has the feel of a classic Northeast country club, which it once was. The course opened to the public in 1998 when Hilton Hotels bought it, then was owned by Caesars Entertainment, but now has returned to being private.As you play several holes along the shoreline, the neon-and-concrete kingdom of AC looms in the distance. The front nine is a brute with four par 4s longer than 445 yards. One of those, the opening hole, charmingly uses a portion of the practice putting green as its tee box. The back nine is much shorter (3,125 yards compared to 3,452 on the front) but also a lot tighter as you wind your way around the marsh. Several shots bring the hazard into play, and the 157-yard 17th is a blind shot over massive sand dunes.ACCC's clubhouse is akin to a golf museum. ACCC played an important part in the history of American golf. Not only did the terms birdie and eagle originate from rounds played there in 1903, but the course was the site of six USGA championships, including the 1901 Amateur and the 1948 Women's Open won by Babe Didrikson Zaharias. Bob Hope regularly played the course. So did boxer Joe Louis and quarterback Joe Namath. Arnold Palmer spent a couple of summers there in the 1950s while serving in the Coast Guard nearby. Everything from the wood lockers to the spike marks on the 19th hole's floor lets you know that you're experiencing a piece of golf's past. --Ron Kaspriske, senior editor
1 / 1
Courtesy of The Trump Organization
Previous rank: 22
Trump National Philadelphia, in Pine Hill, N.J., is a Tom Fazio design with some rolling terrain down the street from Pine Valley. Donald Trump told our John Barton in 2014: "I think it's as good as Pine Valley, OK? People from Pine Valley are playing it all the time, and some say it's just as good, and some say it's better."
1 / 5
Courtesy of the club
2 / 5
Courtesy of the club
3 / 5
Courtesy of the club
4 / 5
Stephen Hennessey
5 / 5
Stephen Hennessey
Previous rank: 21
Morris County Country Club gets lost among the unthinkably good golf in the Tri-State area, but the Golden Age design is finally getting its due, thanks to recent tree-removal work and impeccable conditioning—allowing the bold landforms and land movement to shine. Widely accepted to be a Seth Raynor design, recent discovery from the club revealed C.B. Macdonald worked here, too. The Morristown club also holds the distinction of being the first club in the country organized and managed by women. The course continues to make improvements, now under the supervision of consulting architect Jaeger Kovich of Proper Golf, who previously worked under Gil Hanse and Tom Doak as a builder and shaper.
1 / 8
Dana Fry
2 / 8
Dana Fry
3 / 8
Dana Fry
4 / 8
Dana Fry
5 / 8
Dana Fry
6 / 8
Dana Fry
7 / 8
Jon Cavalier
8 / 8
Jon Cavalier
Previous rank: 18
Dana Fry designed and built this course in 2001 with then partner Dr. Michael Hurdzan, and in 2022 came back to do a renovation with current partner Jason Straka. The original design featured elaborate MacKenzie-inspired cape-and-bay bunkers, now replaced by what might be considered a more traditional, or New England, style of shaping with less formality. Their placements have also been adjusted, as have tees, while some fairways were re-graded and hundreds of trees were removed to better show off the 730-acre estate’s surrounding pastures and woods.
1 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
2 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
3 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
4 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
5 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
6 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
7 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
8 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
9 / 9
Courtesy of Dormie Network
Previous rank: 19
Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw are known for their minimalist designs with quiet undulation and ridges—Hidden Creek fits nicely in their portfolio. Like many other Coore-Crenshaw works, Hidden Creek offers wide fairways that emphasize finding the best angle to give yourself the best chance to score. The course offers a great mix of doglegs in both directions, and there is quite a good variety in the par-4s, including the short par-4 8th that is one of the highlights of the round. The par-3s are quite impressive too, as they range from 230 to 115. Hidden Creek is one of the best courses in the Dormie Network’s stable and more than holds its own in comparison to the other courses in the region.
1 / 10
Courtesy of the club
2 / 10
Evan Schiller
3 / 10
Evan Schiller
4 / 10
Courtesy of the club
5 / 10
Courtesy of the club
6 / 10
Courtesy of the club
7 / 10
Courtesy of the club
8 / 10
Courtesy of the club
9 / 10
Courtesy of the club
10 / 10
Evan Schiller
Previous rank: 17
Set in the northern portion of New Jersey’s Pine Barrens, the course weaves through pine trees on gently sloping ground. Opening and closing holes on each nine play down and then back up the hill, which is the dominant landform that adds interest to the routing. Robert Trent Jones Sr. and Roger Rulewich routed all 27 holes through the pines and local marsh, creating a course that challenges a player’s ability to navigate uneven lies and elevation changes. Missing the fairway here will leave a golfer amid the pines, often with a difficult recovery. A recent bunker renovation opened up views on some holes while widening the landing area on others. Originally opened in 1987, Metedeconk National has occupied a spot in Golf Digest’s Best in State almost every year since.
1 / 2
Courtesy of the club
2 / 2
Courtesy of the club
Previous rank: 16
Big and brawny Arcola Country Club continues to get better year after year—as competitors found out at the 2022 U.S. Amateur when it co-hosted stroke-play qualifying with neighboring Ridgewood Country Club. Robert Trent Jones redesigned the course in the 1950s after the state acquired part of the property through the construction of the nearby Garden State Parkway, which eliminated four existing holes. Paul Dotti, the club’s Director of Grounds since 2009, has conducted some major projects to elevate Arcola’s stature in the state, performing major drainage work, tree removal, and rebuilding and reshaping bunkers and fairways. Dotti’s crew maintains some of the best conditioned playing conditions in the tri-state area—a bold statement given the depth of great layouts with incredible maintenance staffs—but on any given day, golfers will encounter firm-and-fast conditions with putting surfaces rolling above 14 on the Stimpmeter. The championship venue also hosts the annual Arcola Cup, which hosts some of the best amateur players in the area.
More From Golf Digest
1 / 1
Courtesy of the Trump Organization
Previous rank: 11
The highest-ranked Trump-owned course, the Old Course at Trump National Bedminster, hosted the 2017 U.S. Women's Open and was set to host the 2022 PGA Championship before the PGA of America moved the event to Southern Hills. The Fazio design, which opened in 2004, was ranked as high as 141st on our America's Second 100 Greatest rankings in 2013-2014—and 165th in 2015-2016—before falling off our rankings for not having enough ballots to meet our minimum evaluation count.
1 / 4
Jon Cavalier
2 / 4
Jon Cavalier
3 / 4
Jon Cavalier
4 / 4
Jon Cavalier
Previous rank: 14
Northeast of Princeton is The Ridge at Back Brook, another of those great pieces of property Tom Fazio is given on which to build a course. With 150 feet of natural elevation change, Fazio had little need to reshape the landscape, although he still had crews re-carve fairways for visibility and flow. With patches of mature forest of hardwoods and cedars, Fazio had little need to import trees, although a few were transplanted to emphasize seclusion on particular holes. The front nine sits in a valley formed by meandering Back Brook, while much of the back nine is on a plateau high above the front nine. Rock outcroppings are a prominent feature, including a massive one that poses a cross-hazard on the par-5 seventh, veins of rock behind the ninth and 18th greens and the namesake vertical cliff that provides a stunning backdrop to the par-3 eighth.
1 / 2
Evan Schiller Photography
2 / 2
Previous rank: 15
The backbone of this super-maximalist design from Dana Fry and Jason Straka in the South New Jersey cape is a pair of constructed 40-foot-high central ridges that half of the complex’s 27 holes scramble up and down. The design is a head-spinning presentation of three different nines that show off electrified putting surfaces stuffed with all manner of tiers, baubles and side slopes, big sandy dunes, scrubby barrens, cavernous bunkers, a section on the north end that mimics holes forged from a quarry and a kaleidoscope of native New Jersey vegetation. The new Union League National earned second-place honors in our 2022 Best New Private award.
1 / 10
Evan Schiller
2 / 10
Evan Schiller
3 / 10
Evan Schiller
4 / 10
Evan Schiller
5 / 10
Evan Schiller
6 / 10
Evan Schiller
7 / 10
Evan Schiller
8 / 10
Evan Schiller
9 / 10
Evan Schiller
10 / 10
Evan Schiller
Previous rank: 12
Mountain Ridge Country Club has forever been one of North Jersey's great hidden gems, and after fabulous restoration work done over the past 10 years by Ron Prichard, the club is starting to get its due after hosting a number of events, including the 2012 U.S. Senior Amateur on its centennial, the 2020 MET Open and the 2021 LPGA Cognizant Founders Cup. This 250-acre site, perched atop an enormous ridge in West Caldwell, was acquired by the club after a move from nearby West Orange, and the club hired Donald Ross in the late 1920s to route a new 18-hole course, which traverses varied, interesting topography and features some genius putting surfaces. Mountain Ridge had a large-scale celebration in June 1931 to dedicate the Clifford Wendehack clubhouse and new course, of which Ross himself attended. The club has hired Andrew Green to complete a long-term plan to ensure that Mountain Ridge continues to be in the conversation as one of the country’s best-known secrets.
1 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
2 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
3 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
4 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
5 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
6 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
7 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
8 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
9 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
10 / 13
LinksGems
11 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
12 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
13 / 13
Jon Cavalier, LinksGems/Courtesy of the Club
Previous rank: 13
Essex County Country Club has been touched by some of the game’s best designers, with A.W. Tillinghast routing a new layout on the current site in 1918. Seth Raynor kept seven of Tillinghast’s original holes (Nos. 1 through 6 and the ninth) during a 1925 redesign. Before construction began, Raynor passed away, leaving his associate Charles Banks to do the rest. Banks favored the template holes of Raynor and Macdonald, and his brilliant renditions are still standouts today, including a Redan, Double Plateau, Alps, Punchbowl and Eden. A young Gil Hanse extended the course to 7,100 yards, added fairway bunkers and removed thousands of trees in the early 2000s. In the fall of 2023, Hanse and partner Jim Wagner returned to perform some updates and sharpen features—most notably reinvigorating the dogleg-left opening hole—continuing the portfolio of great architects to have worked at this storied New Jersey site.
1 / 5
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
2 / 5
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
3 / 5
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
4 / 5
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
5 / 5
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
Previous rank: 10
Like Bayonne Golf Club to the south, Liberty National Golf Club was a reclamation project, a super-expensive Superfund clean-up of New York harbor, replacing a putrid assortment of oil refineries and storage tanks with an intriguing combination of green grass and golden rough. By spreading 2 million cubic yards of fresh soil over the capped toxic wastes, architect Bob Cupp and pro-consultant Tom Kite started building something meant to be a major tournament venue. It has narrow bent-grass fairways, just 25 to 27 yards wide, and tiny, flawless bent-grass greens, averaging just 3,400 square feet. With several hundred mature hardwoods transplanted along the fairways, a couple of rock-lined streams edging greens and winding cart paths fashioned from brick, Liberty National looks like what Central Park might be if it were a golf course Liberty National sits just three miles southwest of the tip of Manhattan, so the views of the NYC skyline, and the Statue of Liberty, are tremendous.
1 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
2 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
3 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
4 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
5 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
6 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
Previous rank: 7
Galloway National occupies a very fine stretch of South Jersey-pine barrens, a site that before construction had been compared to nearby Pine Valley. But Tom Fazio felt the land more favorably compared with that of Pinehurst, and his dream was to reshape this course the old-fashioned way, using horses and slip-scrapers much as had been done a century ago at Pinehurst. But the economics and timetable didn’t allow him such a fanciful luxury. Instead, bulldozers were used to shove the sand around into graceful fairways and low-slung, fall-away greens. Pines and roughs of pine needles frame most holes and the eastern flank of the course runs directly along a tidal marsh that leads to the Atlantic. Galloway National now has enough exposed sand, by the way, that golfers today are reminded of both Pinehurst and Pine Valley.
1 / 6
Courtesy of Evan schiller
2 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
3 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
4 / 6
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
5 / 6
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
6 / 6
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
Previous rank: 9
Bayonne Golf Club and its neighbor Liberty National Golf Club were built at the same time, part of a massive transformation of the Jersey shoreline along the Hudson River and New York Harbor. Bayonne was built on an old sanitary landfill covered with seven million cubic yards of fill, much of it dredged from the harbor to make the channel deep enough for supertankers. The deposits were piled up to 10 stories high, which developer-designer Eric Bergstol then shaped into towering faux sand dunes. The course is an ode to Irish links, with no trees, cart paths or level lies. Fairways flow down narrow valleys, edged by steep slopes laden with tall, wavy fescues. Bunkers are deep and often fearsome. A few greens sit right above the harbor, and all putting surfaces have confounding humps, bumps and rolls. Tucked away down a bumpy, unpaved road past a strip mall in blue-collar Bayonne, N.J., is this private, walking-only enclave.
1 / 10
Benjamin Herms
2 / 10
Benjamin Herms
3 / 10
Benjamin Herms
4 / 10
Benjamin Herms
5 / 10
Benjamin Herms
6 / 10
Benjamin Herms
7 / 10
Benjamin Herms
8 / 10
Benjamin Herms
9 / 10
Benjamin Herms
10 / 10
Benjamin Herms
Previous rank: 8
Walter Travis was a man of many talents. As a player, he won three U.S. Amateur titles and one British Amateur, and his 80-percent match win percentage ranks among the sport’s all-time best. He was a writer, editor and publisher of The American Golfer in addition to designing over two dozen golf courses. His greatest skill might have been bunkering courses. His work revamping Garden City in the early 1900s—adding, moving and deepening the bunkers as well as rebuilding the greens—transformed that course into what it is today, but his most ambitious work is at Hollywood. The elaborate bunker shapes and arrangements are nothing short of dazzling, especially as they’ve been sharpened and polished by Brian Schneider of Renaissance Golf, along with co-designer Blake Conant. They lay out like arrangements of gemstones and the spots on a jungle cat, varying from the size of a mansion parlor to little more than a bread box. Anything like it attempted today would be considered garish, but Travis’ Beaux Arts bunkering at Hollywood is a study in artistry.
1 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
2 / 9
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
3 / 9
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
4 / 9
Courtesy of Jon Cavalier
5 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
6 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
7 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
8 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
9 / 9
Courtesy of Evan Schiller
Previous rank: 6
Ridgewood was always one of A.W. Tillinghast’s favorites. He lived nearby, was a club member and a close friend with the club's longtime pro, George Jacobus, who served as president of the PGA of America for seven years. (It was Jacobus who brought the 1935 Ryder Cup to Ridgewood.) The 27 holes that Tillinghast created were some of his most demanding. Not surprisingly, the course has long been a tournament venue, particularly in recent years, following extensive tree removal and bunker renovation by Gil Hanse and Jim Wagner. Ridgewood’s tournament 18 consists of holes from all three nines, and that's the configuration our panelists score. The club’s drivable par-4 sixth on its Center nine, the famed “Five and Dime” hole, is one of the country's greats, built long before potentially one-shot par 4s became trendy.
More From Golf Digest
1 / 1
USGA/Fred Vuich
Previous rank: 5
In the late 1990s, Gil Hanse and his team gradually began restoring all of Plainfield’s Donald Ross features, including many that had become covered by trees or lost over the years. During the early 2000s, every green, fairway, teeing ground, chipping area and bunker was restored. Meanwhile, excessive trees were removed. The result is an exceptional restoration/renovation of one of Donald Ross’ very best designs, and it could not be more fun to play every day. The tree removal also opened up strategic playing angles, optionality and stunning views across the property. The course remains a great venue for competitions as well, with USGA and PGA Tour events producing an impressive list of champions, including John Cook, Laura Davies, Dustin Johnson and Jason Day. Plainfield has committed to three future USGA Championships, including the 2025 U.S. Amateur Four-Ball, 2031 U.S. Senior Women’s Open and the 2037 U.S. Senior Open.
1 / 9
Evan Schiller
2 / 9
Evan Schiller
3 / 9
Evan Schiller
4 / 9
Evan Schiller
5 / 9
Evan Schiller
6 / 9
Evan Schiller
7 / 9
Evan Schiller
8 / 9
9 / 9
Previous rank: 4
It’s believed that when A.W. Tillinghast began constructing the Upper and Lower Courses at Baltusrol in 1919 (replacing Baltusrol’s existing 18 holes), it was the first contiguous 36 holes built at the same time in America. Because of the Lower’s tremendous major championship record, most consider the slightly shorter Upper to be a secondary course at the club. But between the two, it was the Upper, not the Lower, that hosted the first U.S. Open (and third in the club’s history) in 1936, won by Tony Manero. The Lower didn’t get its first Open until 1954, won by Ed Furgol. Baltusrol Mountain, just 200 feet high, looms above the right flank of the Upper, complicating drives and putts with a landscape that tilts more than appears to the eye. Gil Hanse and Jim Wagner restored the Tillinghast architecture to the Lower Course in 2020 with the ancillary goal of enhancing its tournament bite. Their job at the club’s Upper course, reopened in summer 2025, was simpler: Bring back the Tillinghast. This included significant tree removal, major green expansions (including the addition of a lost alternate green at the par-4 14th), bunker restoration/relocation and new sub-surface air systems. Both the Upper and Lower have long been known for strong opening and finishing sequences, but the Upper’s beautifully revived middle holes, moving across the more interesting terrain, now make the case for the courses being on equal architectural footing, if not in championship mettle.
1 / 9
Jeff Bertch/Courtesy of the club
2 / 9
3 / 9
David Wilson/Courtesy of the club
4 / 9
Jon Cavalier, @LinksGems/Courtesy of the club
5 / 9
James Anderson/Courtesy of the club
6 / 9
James Anderson/Courtesy of the club
7 / 9
Courtesy of Somerset Hills CC
8 / 9
Robert Walker
9 / 9
Robert Walker
Previous rank: 3
Somerset Hills is another marvelous A.W. Tillinghast design, one of the few that has remained virtually unchanged since it opened in 1918. So, it may be the most authentic Tillinghast course on the 100 Greatest. It’s a charming, laid-back design that works through seemingly undisturbed rolling terrain, past rock outcroppings and around small-but-distinctive water hazards. Tilly designed this with a spoonful of whimsy, with “dolomite” mounds edging one green and startling knobs within another putting surface. Like Baltusrol Upper, Somerset Hills has a Tillinghast version of a Redan par 3, the second hole, which Golf Digest panelists ranked higher than any of the many splendid versions created by C.B. Macdonald or Seth Raynor, the pioneers of the template in the United States.
1 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
2 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
3 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
4 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
5 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
6 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
7 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
8 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
9 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
10 / 12
Evan Schiller/Courtesy of the club
11 / 12
12 / 12
Previous rank: 2
Jack Nicklaus won two U.S. Opens on Baltusrol's Lower Course, setting a tournament record each time. Phil Mickelson and Jimmy Walker won PGAs on it. But the Lower’s most historic event was the ace by architect Robert Trent Jones in 1954 on the par-3 fourth, instantly squelching complaints of critical club members who felt Trent’s redesign made it too hard. Trent’s younger son, Rees, an avowed A.W. Tillinghast fan, lightly retouched the Lower’s design for the 2016 PGA Championship. But there has been another changing of the guard at Baltusrol, as architect Gil Hanse and his team took over as the club’s new consulting architects, and re-opened the restored Lower course—after carefully examining Tilly's old plans and reclaiming green sizes and rebuilding bunkers—in May 2021. Hanse's team performed a similar restoration on Baltusrol's Upper course, which reopened in May 2025.
1 / 8
Carlos Amoedo
2 / 8
Dom Furore
3 / 8
Dom Furore
4 / 8
Courtesy of the club/Charley Raudenbush
5 / 8
Photo by Dom Furore
6 / 8
Dom Furore
7 / 8
Golf Digest/Photo by Dom Furore
8 / 8
Photo by Dom Furore
Previous rank: 1
A genuine original, its unique character is forged from the sandy pine barrens of southwest Jersey. Founder George Crump had help from now-legendary architects H.S. Colt, A.W. Tillinghast, George C. Thomas Jr. and Walter Travis. Hugh Wilson (of Merion fame) and his brother Alan finished the job, while William Flynn and Perry Maxwell made revisions. Throughout the course, Pine Valley blends all three schools of golf design—penal, heroic and strategic—often times on a single hole. Recent tree removal at selected spots has revealed some gorgeous views of the sandy landscape upon which the course is routed, and Tom Fazio has put his own touch on the design with bunker remodels that have given the barrens a more intricate and ornate look.
More From Golf Digest
• • •
Explore Golf Digest's new Course Reviews section where you can submit a star rating and evaluation on all the courses you’ve played. We've collected tens of thousands of reviews from our course-ranking panelists to deliver a premium experience, which includes course rankings, experts' opinions, bonus course photography, videos and much more. Check it out here!