PGA Championship 2025: Justin Thomas accidentally gave a damning assessment of Quail Hollow
Ben Jared
CHARLOTTE — Critics of this week's PGA Championship venue have found their perfect rallying cry, courtesy of Justin Thomas' unguarded moment of brutal honesty.
Quail Hollow commands the spotlight as it hosts the PGA of America’s flagship event, marking its second coronation as a major championship venue. The Charlotte mainstay has steadily climbed golf's hosting hierarchy, having staged the 2022 Presidents Cup while maintaining its long-standing position as the PGA Tour's premier Carolina stop. This elevation stems not from architectural brilliance but the course's irresistible appeal to golf's governing bodies—specifically, its financial prowess, with deep-pocketed sponsors, guaranteed revenue streams, and the Charlotte market's corporate appetite for luxury hospitality experiences.
.jpg.rend.hgtvcom.1280.853.suffix/1573162573968.jpeg)
Courtesy of PGA of America
.jpg.rend.hgtvcom.1280.853.suffix/1573162575006.jpeg)
Courtesy of PGA of America
The green at the narrow 15th is typically Quail Hollow’s hardest to reach in regulation.
.jpg.rend.hgtvcom.1280.853.suffix/1573162556261.jpeg)
Courtesy of Gary Kellner/PGA of America
.jpg.rend.hgtvcom.1280.853.suffix/1573162557586.jpeg)
Courtesy of Gary Kellner/PGA of America
The uphill 12th with water left and right is listed as a par 5 but will take scores of 4s and even 3s to win.
Beneath the tournament infrastructure and corporate chalets, however, lurks an inconvenient truth acknowledged throughout the architecture community. Quail Hollow represents a troubling philosophical approach to course design—a monument to an era when designers confused intimidation for inspiration. While golf's transcendent venues engage players in a dance of strategic options and calculated risks, Quail Hollow conducts a cross-examination with virtually one question repeated throughout: "Can you hit it far enough?" Its sprawling fairways demand not creative shot-making but rather metronomic power production, and despite its formidable difficulty, Quail lacks that ineffable quality that permeates the grounds of exceptional courses. Former PGA Tour champion Hunter Mahan crystallized this sentiment with surgical precision in an interview with the Athletic, comparing Quail Hollow to the Kardashian family—visually impressive yet substantively hollow.
Yet the most revealing critique emerged inadvertently from Thomas—who earned his first major championship at Quail in 2017—whose candor exposed this setup’s architectural shortcomings more decisively than any design critic possibly could. Speaking to the media Tuesday ahead of this week’s championship, Thomas was asked a question about why reigning Masters winner Rory McIlroy tends to play well here, as McIlroy has four titles at Quail. What began as praise for McIlroy turned into a Quail drive-by.
“First and foremost, he's really, really good at golf, so that definitely helps,” Thomas said. “I would argue he's the best driver of the ball I've ever seen, and that is extremely important here. But I think his shot shape, I think this golf course fits a high draw really, really well. There's a lot of tee shots, whether it's holding fairways or fitting doglegs, taking bunkers out of play, whatever it is. He just has—when he's on, he has such control of that driver, it seems like he can hit it in a window and an area that some guys are trying to hit short irons.
“That's a tremendous advantage or threat at any golf course, but I feel like a place like this, where it doesn't necessarily require a lot of thought or strategy off the tee, it's generally pulling out driver and just I need to hit this as far and straight as possible, and he's really, really good at that. That's something, like I said, that is an advantage at any golf course, but I think just the shot shape and that is a good combination.”
Doesn’t necessarily require a lot of thought or strategy. That won't grace the pro shop’s merchandise anytime soon.
Quail and PGA of America officials might find comfort knowing Thomas' assessment is more of an indictment on the debate around distance gains and its governance. Still, Monday's torrential downpour and the week's forecast of on-and-off rain likely ensures Thomas' diagnosis proves prophetic: Saturated fairways will further neutralize strategic options, rendering Quail Hollow exactly what Thomas described—a behemoth demanding nothing more sophisticated than launching missiles into the horizon, a chess match turned into Tic-tac-toe.
