JOIN NOW
Advertisement

Our swing robot caught Mizuno's Pro S-1 iron breaking its own category's rules

/content/dam/images/golfdigest/fullset/2022/DSC_02402.JPG
September 25, 2026
Save for later

Put 30 irons through testing on the Golf Laboratories swing robot, and outliers turn up, especially once the focus narrows to spin and carry consistency across the six impact locations we test on the face.

Spin and carry consistency are generally driven by two things: loft and head design. Traditional lofts generate more spin off a higher launch angle, and more spin generally leads to less carry. Head design matters just as much: a larger, perimeter-weighted head packed with technology retains carry better on a miss than a forged compact blade does. None of that is a revelation to anyone who follows equipment.

Look at the graphic built around those two numbers, though, and one corner stands out: high spin paired with a tight carry pattern, two things that aren't supposed to happen together. Nine of the 10 irons there make sense once you check their category. Callaway's Quantum Max OS and Cobra's Baffler are super-game-improvement. PXG's 0311P Gen 8 is players-distance. TaylorMade's Qi Max is game-improvement. Those categories are built around wide soles and low centers of gravity that allow golfers who struggle to get the ball airborne to maximize distance through higher spin.

/content/dam/images/golfdigest/fullset/2022/s1-1.jpg

The 10th club, however, has no business being there: Mizuno's Pro S-1, a muscleback blade boasting one of the smallest heads and built-in margins of any iron in the test.

The S-1 spins as much as almost anything in the field, third-highest of all 30 irons. By the pattern governing everything else in that corner of the graphic, its carry should be loose, like nearly every other players iron we tested. Instead the gap between what its spin predicts and what it actually delivers, 2.5 yards, is the widest in the whole field except for Quantum Max OS, a head that's actually supposed to be there.

None of that is an accident. Players-iron users want more traditional lofts and more spin to work the ball, not to mention the steeper descent angles that bring the ball down steep enough to check up on a green. High spin in a blade isn't a cost but rather the whole point of the design, and it's why pros continue to rely on them. The carry numbers are consistent and predictable.

/content/dam/images/golfdigest/fullset/2022/DSC_02412.JPG

The drawback comes in the quadrant where nearly every players-iron lives on the graphic: high-spin, loose-carry. Eight of the category's ten possess this combination.

What makes S-1 unique is how it's able to maintain high spin control without paying the usual carry tax on off-center strikes. Its carry spread is a hair, .03 yards, behind PXG's 0311T Gen 8 for tightest blade in the field, but it's important to point out that S-1 is forged from a single billet of 1025E mild carbon steel, while the 0311T features a hollow-body construction with a polymer-filled internal cavity.

For a blade with this little margin to hold that tight a pattern, something specific has to be happening. Mizuno reworked the S-1's sole against its predecessor, the Pro 241, adding a flatter camber, sharper leading edge and two additional degrees of bounce, changes the company says cut down on digging and add forgiveness on shallow attack angles.

/content/dam/images/golfdigest/fullset/2022/mizzycomp-1.jpg

Half of our test protocol is built around exactly that kind of low-face contact, so a sole reworked to survive a shallow strike is a direct mechanical answer. The channel along the back does similar work, repositioning mass to where the center of gravity is located, language Mizuno uses to describe stability and flight control.

None of that shows up in a spin number or a carry number, and nothing in the robot data proves Mizuno's stated design goals are the actual cause. But the result needed an explanation, and there's one available: a sole built specifically to resist the exact contact our low-zone testing isolates.

Based on the robot data and what we observed, S-1 is a blade doing a game-improvement iron's job on a blade's terms.