ColourPop Total Essentials Crème Gel Liner Set

Another twofer, these glide-on eye-liners have been fan favorites, so the cruelty-free brand just released an updated version that’s now waterproof. They can also work as eye shadow if you blend them out a bit with your finger or a brush if you’re feeling fancy. Heck, you could even draw stars on your cheeks or spell out “b-o-g-e-y” across your forehead if that would make you happy (or get a laugh out of your foursome). Also available in practically every color of the rainbow.