Ratings from our panel of 1,900 course-ranking panelists
1 / 1
“One of the most unique and memorable 9-holers out there, Shelter Island AKA Goat Hill is a wild ride with blind shots on every hole except one and extremely firm, fast conditions. The 9th hole is a wonderful par 3 any course would be happy to have. This is a very polarizing course, but one everybody should play once."