Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Jeff Marsh
Philadelphia Country Club: Spring Mill
Philadelphia Country Club: Spring Mill
1601 Spring Mill Rd
Gladwyne, PA 19035-1020
United States
Overview
The original 18 at Philadelphia Country Club, known as Spring Mill, was designed by William Flynn in 1927 (Tom Fazio later added an additional nine holes in 1990, called Centennial). The appropriate word to describe the course and the property is “grand,” especially after Jim Nagle’s 2023 and 2024 renovation work expanded fairways and greens, upscaled the bunkering to better match Flynn’s original hazards and opened up the remaining sight lines so the full scale of the land’s movements and vistas across the west Philadelphia horizon could be appreciated. The design is full of standout holes like the uphill, double-dogleg second, the sweeping downhill fourth and the par-3 seventh nestled in a cove. But the second nine stretch of holes, particularly from the par-5 12th walking along a high ridgeline through the powerful dogleg right 17th that banks through a valley corridor into a green sitting in a secluded hollow are in a class with the best of any course in the Philadelphia market. Philadelphia Country Club was the site of the 1939 U.S. Open, won by Byron Nelson only after an additional 36-hole playoff with Craig Wood and Denny Shute. The tournament may be most remembered, however, as Sam Snead’s best chance to win the Open. Playing the 72nd hole, he needed only par to win but thought he needed a birdie to tie Nelson. After driving the ball in a bunker on the par-5 18th, he elected to go for the green with his 2½ wood instead of laying up with an iron. That shot caught another bunker under the lip and he proceeded to make an 8. The infamous hole is now the par-5 third—the sequencing changed when the clubhouse was relocated to the other side of the course in the 1970s.
About
Awards
Ranking history:
Best in State: Top 10 in state 1987-'95, 2001 & 2009-'11; Top 15, 1997-1999, 2003-2007, 2013-'14, 2019-'22 & 2025-'26; Top 20, 2021-'24.
Previous ranking: 20th.
2025-'26 ranking: 13th.
Panelists
Ratings from our panel of 1,900 course-ranking panelists
100 GREATEST/BEST IN STATE SCORES
Shot Options
Character
Challenge
Layout Variety
Fun
Aesthetics
Conditioning
Reviews
Review
“Excellent Golden Age Flynn desing in on the Mainline in the suburbs of Philadelphia. The course was recently renovated - trees were removed which adds better sightlines and opens up vistas to various holes. Bunkers were redone and fairways and rough were reseeded. Tees were added to test the lenght of the modern player. The design makes tremedous use of the rolling hills on the property. Holes are nicely varied - several uphill and downhill wiht a nice mix of doglegs and varying lenthged Par 3"s and 4's. Flynn places a myriad of strategic bunkers that a golfer must confront on both tee shot and approach to the greens. The Par 3 5th is an expectional mid-length par 3. Plahying down hill and 181 yards from the back tees, the small green is guarded by a creek that meanders in front and to the right of the green. Two bunkers gaurd the left side if a golfer choses to play more conservatively. Par 5 3rd and 12th have been stretched to 601 and 619 yards respectively which fairway and cross bunkers making it even more challenging. 17 and 18 are long doglegs right and left also providing ample challenge. Greens are interesting with both subtle breaks and slopes. A gem in what is a a crowded field of excellent venues in the Philadelhia area."
Read More2025
Review
“Really good diversity of holes up/down terrain, long/short par 4's/5's, doglegs and straight. Played after renovation think the changes (tree removal, trap changes) opened up the beauty of the land offering panoramic views from several holes. The one change I question is the fall off on the front of the green on the 6th hole coupled with a false front down a steep hill. Overpenalizes a decent shot to the green. Loved the opening two "warm up" holes and relatively easy par 5 third before getting to the teeth of the course. Used virtually every club in the bag on approach shots and Par 3's including a driver on the 15th Par 3. Conditioning of the course was magnificent fairways in early November perfect and greens consistent even though punched just a few weeks ago. The many sand traps had nice white sand although some areas thin and others thick."
Read More2025
Review
“Really good diversity of holes up/down terrain, long/short par 4's/5's, doglegs and straight. Played after renovation think the changes (tree removal, trap changes) opened up the beauty of the land offering panoramic views from several holes. The one change I question is the fall off on the front of the green on the 6th hole coupled with a false front down a steep hill. Overpenalizes a decent shot to the green. Loved the opening two "warm up" holes and relatively easy par 5 third before getting to the teeth of the course. Used virtually every club in the bag on approach shots and Par 3's including a driver on the 15th Par 3. Conditioning of the course was magnificent fairways in early November perfect and greens consistent even though punched just a few weeks ago. The many sand traps had nice white sand although some areas thin and others thick."
Read More2025
Review
“A classic Philadelphia layout not to be missed!"
Read More2025
Review
“Philadelphia CC really changed (and for the better) since I last played it. I loved the vistas that were opened up with the tree removal plan but was happy to see that many specimen trees remained to help frame holes as well as to provide alignment aids. Flynn used the topography to great advantage, and even though some hole run parallel to each other, they do not play back to back so they do not feel repetitive. Even with the renovations, William Flynn’s original routing has stood the test of time. The renovation of the 18th hole, which was severely impinged by the prior clubhouse expansion, is a great improvement. The hole was lengthened and moved down the slope to take the clubhouse out of harm’s way. Most greens offer the option to run the ball on, but some require a forced carry over bunkers. Several holes, notably the par four 17th, reward a well struck long drive across the dogleg without which the green cannot be reached in two shots (by most golfers). The fairways were enlarged to a width of 50 yards or more, offset by lengthening the course with new back tees for the 2026 US Amateur."
Read More2025
Review
“Philadelphia Country Club is one of the best courses in an area full of great golf heritage. The strong layout variety and shot options present a full set of challenges for even the most accomplished golfer. The conditioning is always top notch and the hills and trees create a beautiful backdrop and landscape thru which to play a round of golf."
Read More2023
Review
“Philadelphia Country Club (Spring/Mill) is an excellent golf course that is worthy of its strong golf course peers in the area. The routing gives the golfer an ever-changing challenge as it winds its way through the hills and trees of suburban Philadelphia. The journey begins with a relatively straight-forward 1st hole that while short has a green complex with numerous devilish placements. The breaks are subtle, but sometimes severe given the typically fast green speeds. The 2nd hole while also short, poses another set of challenges both off the tee, but especially on the approach to a well elevated and guarded green. A precise approach is required here. The course begins to open itself up on the 3rd hole with a long, uphill par 5 that requires well struck shots all the way - again to a well guarded, elevated green. The course has a series of long par 4s that make up a lot of the challenge. The 4th is a prime example of this. While playing slightly downhill, it still requires 2 long and well-struck shots to reach this green. The 5th is the first of 4 fantastic par 3s that many think are the hallmark of this course. With variety in length and elevation (2 downhill, one flat and one uphill) this is a very strong set of par 3s. The closing set of holes are truly standout. The long, downhill par 4 14th, followed by the most challenging uphill long par 3 15th. Then the short par 4 16th which has one of the most difficult greens to hit and hold on the course. The 17th is the signature hole. A long dogleg right playing up to and then down a big hill, over a pond and around the corner of trees to a wonderful green complex. There is a plate in the fairway honoring Byron Nelson's famed 1-iron that he holed from 215 yards out. Typically you'll find many divots from others who attempt the same feat! Overall, PCC is an outstanding course and well deserving of its top marks."
Read More2023
Review
“An old classic with lay of the land in its routing that consisted of strategic bunkers, quick greens with movement, and blue grass rough that eats golf balls."
Read More2023
Review
“William Flynn design in 1927, home of the 1939 US Open. Course rolls through the hills and valleys in Lower Merion, with few level lies and smaller, undulating greens. A caddie is a benefit when you play to help you with sight lines and reads on the putting surfaces, but not required. Pace of play is watched closely, with a goal of 4 hours."
Read More2022
Review
“Another Flynn design that was a great mix of short and long holes with small greens. The elevation changes on many holes made for interesting ambience and the conditioning of the golf course was firm and fast but receptive greens that rolled very true. Great experience in a great location in Philly."
Read More2018