Golf Digest editors picks

Reaction

Results for December 2012 Back to #Reaction Index

Golf Digest editors discuss the inspiration behind our January 2013 cover


JANUARY2013GD.jpgInspiration for our best conceptual ideas here at Golf Digest come in different shapes and sizes. Often times, a brainstorming conversation on the golf course among editors and writers will spur a feature. Or perhaps a meeting, with all of our minds working together, results in a new project.

One of our most popular covers of the year, the January 2013 issue of Golf Digest (see Letters to the Editor below), however, was the product of some field research by our Style Editor, Marty Hackel.

Mr. Style tells the story about how he was at the prestigious Wentworth Club this summer, at a formal dinner in which PGA Tour stars Rory McIlroy and Graeme McDowell attended. The Northern Irishmen were dressed to the nines in tuxedos, laughing and enjoying themselves. His mind instantly recalled one of his favorite photographs, the famous Slim Aarons' shot "Kings of Hollywood" from 1957.

"I thought, 'We could do a really cool shot if we recreated the shot in the Kings of Wentworth, in that image," Hackel says. "I wanted to take a picture with my camera phone in the front of the hotel, but because we couldn't find two other tour players, I just kept the image in the back of my mind."

SlimAarons_Reaction0113.jpg

"Kings of Hollywood" was taken by legendary photographer Slim Aarons at Romanoff's in Beverly Hills during a New Year's party in 1957. From left to right: Clark Gable, Van Heflin, Gary Cooper and James Stewart laugh about Aarons' brief acting bit in an upcoming movie.

When it came time to plan out our annual Buddies trip issue, which this year featured a ranking from our 1,100 golf-course panelists on their favorite places to visit with their friends, in addition to a piece by senior writer Tim Rosaforte on buddies trips taken by PGA Tour players, Mr. Style's acute memory served us well.

"Often we've focused on buddies-trip guides to specific locations, like Las Vegas (2011) or Myrtle Beach (2010)," says Pete Finch, our Senior Editor of special projects and the editor of our buddies package. "This year we asked the supremely plugged-in Tim Rosaforte to brief us on the world of buddies within professional golf, an area we hadn't given much attention to in the past. That's what our fun cover shot featuring McDowell, McIlroy, Lee Westwood and Ian Poulter is all about."

The result was a photo shoot at pristine Liberty National, in the shadows of New York City, in which we asked legendary photographer, Golf Digest's Walter Iooss Jr. to execute Mr. Style's image. Just like Slim Aarons had captured the moment shared by Clark Gable, Van Heflin, Gary Cooper and James Stewart at a New Year's party in Beverly Hills in 1957, the four European stars were photographed enjoying themselves on the fairways of Liberty National.

"I told [the four Euro Ryder Cup players] the story behind the Aarons photo before our shoot, and they got a big kick out of it," Mr. Style says.

"The cover was really Marty's vision which he pulled off perfectly," adds Golf Digest Director of Photography Christian Iooss.

Response to our January 2013 cover has been overwhelmingly positive—we included a selection of comments from our readers below:

"Dear Golf Digest, WOW!!!! I am completely in awe over this months cover!!! Your cover boys are a visual embodiment of the game!!! I asked my daughter if she wanted Teen Vogue and she said, "No way, Golf Digest!" She is the lone golfer in our home. We enjoy discussing the articles and deepen our knowledge of the game. Bravo at a standout cover!!!!" -- Libby Almeida, El Dorado Hills, Calif.

"Thank you for the great cover photograph of members of the European team on the January 2013 issue. Whether by design or by accident, I believe you captured eloquently a piece of why we lost the Ryder Cup. The obvious camaraderie; conviviality and friendship along with complete comfort in who they are is captured in this photograph and contributed mightily to the "team" effort that once again we could not equal. Once again, a picture is worth a thousand words. I hope Tom Watson asks you for copies to be provided to all his players at the appropriate time." --John Robertson, Carmel, Ind.

"Dear Editor, First of all, congratulations on the excellent cover of the 01/2013 edition of Golf Digest. I love it! . . . Reading Golf Digest is truly inspirational and educational to me. Thank you!" --Rafael Torres Antonioli, Wexford, Pa.

And please continue to send us your feedback throughout 2013, as we'll be responding to your notes periodically in the new year. (mailto:Letters@golfdigest.com).


Stephen Hennessey

Reaction to announcement of Tom Watson's 2014 Ryder Cup captaincy

By Stephen Hennessey

It's official.

The PGA of America announced Thursday morning — following Tuesday's report from our Tim Rosaforte — that the U.S. Ryder Cup captain for 2014 will be Tom Watson.

After the announcement on the "Today" show with NBC's Matt Lauer, the golf world began reacting to the news that Watson would assume the captaincy again 21 years after his win at the Belfry in 1993.

The initial buzz seemed to be overwhelmingly positive from most U.S. golf fans. It even had Tom Watson and "Ryder Cup" trending on Twitter, impressive for golf to create such worldwide discussion in December.

A couple of examples:

From Golf Digest's Facebook page: Scott Rich: "Simply the best! USA heading back to the winner's circle!!"

Larry Silman: "Good news. No more analysis paralysis. Play the hot hands. Bench the cold ones. Egos checked at the door."

Tyrone Haskett: "They couldn't have made a better choice."

From Anthony Distler (@Anthdistler on Twitter): "It's official -- Tom Watson has been named Ryder Cup captain. Great day in golf! What a gentleman, and the perfect captain."

D.T on GeoffShackelford.com: "Watson is the perfect captain to shock Tiger out of his Ryder Cup coma. I think this will be a good thing for Tiger, and I believe Tiger will respond with some checks in the win column."

Watson-Belfry-1993.jpg

A victorious group: The 1993 Ryder Cup team, captained by Watson, is the last U.S. team to win on foreign soil. Photograph: Getty Images

DLYGrisse on GolfWRX.com: "The US needs a leader, Tom will have the respect of everyone on the team.  Just cycling through the guys who are almost 50 and still playing the tour does not always give you a good coach.  DLIII was a nice guy, and friends with many, but when I think leader he is not at the top of my list. AND HE WONT BE AFRAID TO MAKE TOUGH DECISIONS....this is important."

The last U.S. captain to lead a winning Ryder Cup team, Paul Azinger in 2008, agreed with the PGA of America on its decision, although there was a contingent of folks calling for him to lead the team again:

Paul Azinger (@PaulAzinger) on Twitter: "Saw tremendous value in having Dave and Raymond's no nonsense old school of thinking at our 2008 RC. Tom will bring that same intangible."

Related: Sirak: Why Watson as Ryder Cup choice is a smart move 

From current Ryder Cuppers: 

Keegan Bradley, who was 7 years old in 1993 when Watson led the team to victory at the Belfry, on Twitter (@Keegan_Bradley): "Congrats to Tom Watson on being named USA Ryder cup captain!!! I hope to have the privilege to play for him."

Dustin Johnson on Twitter (@D_Johnson): "Tom Watson will be 2014 Ryder Cup Capt...love the guy!!! Larry Nelson better get his chance at some point though."

Chip Beck, who owns a 6-2-1 record in three Cups for the U.S., on Twitter (@ChipBeck59): "Congratulations Tom, I know he brings out the best in everyone. He did in me. 1993 Ryder Cup!"

1991 PGA Champ Steve Elkington on Twitter (@ElkPGA): "Tom Watson said last week in Auz "to be Ryder Cup captain again would be cool." So this week the PGA picks him? Now That's cool!!!"

Former player and current broadcaster Arron Oberholser (@ArronOberholser) still thinks three-time major champion Larry Nelson is still getting a raw deal: "Man, who did poor Larry Nelson tick off at @ThePGAofAmerica . Disgraceful boys. At least give him the dignity of a phone call. #cowards"

Related: Nelson disappointed in Ryder Cup captaincy decision

All the recent Ryder Cup talk inspired Ben Crane to take to Twitter, provoked by some playful smack talk between Rory McIlroy and Keegan Bradley yesterday on Twitter.

Ben Crane (@bencranegolf): "I love the Keegan/Rory Ryder Cup banter. Such an electric event. It's why I'm in the gym right now. I want in. #USA"

And Matteo Manassero, who played with Watson, one of his idols, at the 2009 British Open at age 16 on Twitter: "I'm personally very happy for Tom Watson he is such a great man. #RyderCup"

The endless stream of consciousness from writers on Twitter is worthwhile to read, but here's a selection of three tweets that are worth reading:

Golf Digest Executive Editor Mike O'Malley on Twitter (@GD_MikeO): "Asked [Golf World European correspondent] @JohnHuggan to rank following in order of esteem in which they are held by Scots. His answer: "Today: 1 Nicklaus, 2 Watson, 3 Jones."

Golf World Contributing Writer Jim Moriarty (@GWMoriarty) on Twitter: "Tom Watson named Ryder Cup captain. Tiger Woods pulls hammy September 2014."

Dave Tindall, SkySports.com golf writer: "Too old? Tom Watson has come closer to winning a major than Tiger Woods in the last four years."

—Stephen Hennessey

Reaction: Debating the 2014 United States Ryder Cup captain

Davis-Love-III-Ryder-Cup

Davis Love III led the U.S. team out to a four-point lead before Sunday's final round. He admits he still second guesses some of his decisions.  

By Stephen Hennessey

The European cheers from the Matches at Medinah will reverberate in the ears of American golf fans for a long time. Which is why ever since Martin Kaymer holed the clinching putt to cap a memorable European comeback in September, there's been debate over who should captain the next U.S. squad.

The speculation ramped up Tuesday morning when news broke this morning that the PGA of America will announce the next Ryder Cup captain on Thursday at 8:30 a.m. on the "Today" show.

And that speculation actually started this weekend, when Tom Watson told press at the Australian Open that he'd be honored to be captain again. The U.S. has won just twice since the last time Watson was captain, in 1993.

PGA President Ted Bishop said Tuesday afternoon that the PGA has done something different with the captaincy this time around. Does that mean bringing back a 60-something major champion? Maybe Watson, or 65-year-old Larry Nelson, are bigger possibilities than we originally anticipated.

So who will it be?

Counting up more than 300 votes on GeoffShackelford.com, Tom Watson was the pick, earning 32 percent of the vote. 2011 and 2013 Presidents Cup captain Fred Couples came next at 24 percent; three-time major winner Larry Nelson third at 19 percent; and David Toms fourth at 12percent. (Note: 2008 captain Paul Azinger and 2012's frontman Davis Love III were not included as an option.)

Related: Sirak: Watson deserves a nod

GolfChannel.com's Jason Sobel reported that Toms had not spoken with PGA officials ahead of the planned announcement from New York. Is it possible Toms still gets it? Of course. But the 2001 PGA champion is only 45 years old, and actually still ranked 41st in the world, so it's assumed his time will come at some point.

There weren't too many commenters favoring a Toms captaincy, although he's agreed to be one of the favorites:

On our partner site, GolfWRX.com, "Mark from the UK" cautioned against Toms: "Personally, I don't think he has sufficient RC pedigree to justify being captain at only 45, and I don't think he has the correct personality for it either."

It seems that if Watson — age 63 now and a favorite on both sides of the pond — does get it, all golf fans would be happy.

Chuck from Charlottesville, Va., on GeoffShackelford.com: "Tom Watson's captaincy would be a powerful antidote to any American player who, too young or uninformed to understand Ryder Cup history, finds himself intimidated by the performance of more recent European teams. Since Watson announced his willingness to serve, it'd be almost foolhardy to pass up the opportunity, in my opinion. The fact that Watson never won a PGA Championship shouldn't matter, but probably does to PGA leadership, who aren't known for their quality decision making. Still, I'm an optimist."

One more Watson vs. Toms nugget: The 63-year-old, eight-time major champion owns a 10-4-1 record as a competitor in the Ryder Cup. Toms, who's played in three Cups, has a 4-6-2 mark.

The last head honcho of a winning U.S. squad, Azinger, seems to be a popular choice to take the reigns again.

Slackattack on GolfWRX.com: "I wouldn't be against Azinger getting it again.  I also like the thought of Watson getting the nod.......he is so good on links courses which would help neutralize some of the home field advantage for the Euros."

There is an overriding, strong sympathy felt for Nelson, who many feel was passed up by the PGA on too many occasions. He did win the PGA Championship twice.

Here's Christopher Thompson on our Golf World Facebook page: "How about Larry Nelson? He should have never been passed over. Probably part of the reason USA struggles. Golf gods know these things!"

So it's the golf Gods who've wished the European side to continually get the better of the U.S.? Hmm..

Golf World/GolfDigest.com's John Strege echoed a similar sentiment on Twitter, with a cast of doubt: "Here's hoping PGA rights a wrong, makes Larry Nelson the Ryder Cup captain. Three majors, three Ryder Cups (9-3-1 record). #NotBettingOnIt"

One more pro-Nelson sentiment from J.S. on Geoff Shackelford's blog: "There is one right answer here: Larry Nelson. The man deserves the honor and had been passed over for far too long. It's time for the PGA to step up and do the right thing. Is there one person who hasn't been a Capt already that has the record to match Nelson?

"If current PGA Tour players ever cared enough to boost the opinion of the golfing public, they should tell the PGA they will not play in the Ryder Cup unless Larry Nelson is their Captain."

Related: Diaz: Four years later, Azinger's legacy still felt

U.S. fans are understandably passionate about the subject after watching the Euros celebrate on U.S. soil at Medinah.

The one thing they all could agree on: Bring in a captain who will be equally passionate about returning from Gleneagles with the Cup in hand.

—Stephen Hennessey

Photo: Ross Kinnaird/Getty Images

Putting the heckling of Keegan Bradley at the Tiger Woods Challenge in perspective

157272836.jpg

Photo: Keegan Bradley was on the receiving end of some heckling from fans this week at Sherwood C.C. Courtesy of Stephen Dunn/Getty Images.

By Stephen Hennessey

It seems like we've entered another era of golf.

No, this isn't a post about the young generation of champion golfers, but the increase in popularity of fans letting their voices continually be heard at PGA Tour events.

Unlike other professional sports where loud noise is commonplace, our game is associated with an etiquette and tradition. Yet there still appears to be a divide amongst golf fans whether heckling and random bursts of yelling should be tolerated or not.

Keegan Bradley was on the receiving end of some heckling last weekend at the Tiger Woods Challenge at Sherwood C.C. A report describes a member of the gallery yelling at Bradley on the final hole, calling him a "cheater" in light of the recent news of golf's ruling bodies banning anchoring.

Related: Golf's ruling bodies propose anchoring ban

Bradley dismissed it, but Graeme McDowell, who won the tournament and played in the same group as Bradley, took the opportunity to comment on the growing fan participation on tour these days.

From McDowell's post-round comments: "I'm kind of fed up with all this 'mashed potatoes"' and all this rubbish that the crowd are kind of enjoying shouting right now.

"Keegan had a guy out there who was after every shot he was, 'Yabba- Dabba Doing,' and it was just stupid. It's something, for the players, it's not a lot of fun and it's kind of becoming a little bit of a cool thing to do for the spectators. It kind of gives them their two or three seconds of fame."

Related: USGA rushes to Bradley's defense over anchoring heckler

The pulse on our social channels seems to be somewhat divided, but there's little debate when it comes to explaining such behavior. In many eyes, the main culprit is alcohol.

From Gordon Peters on Twitter (@GPeteLaw), as he replied to @GolfDigestMag:  "Entitlement issues that come with ticket purchase and alcohol."

From FourPutter in a comment on GeoffShackelford.com: "Of course it's all to do with the excess of alcohol which is so freely available all round the courses these days. But the TV announcers call the drunken behaviour atmosphere and character. I call itloutish rudeness, and I didn't invite a bunch of drunks into my living room when I want to watch golf. The worst of all is that tournament in Arizona (Phoenix?) where everyone appears to be completely sloshed. If I were a player I'd just pass on it."

With the price of alcohol as high as it is at pro events, beer sales fund a lot of operations, so we don't see this stopping any time soon. And actual heckling in golf doesn't seem to be popular, aside from the annual PGA Tour stop at TPC Scottsdale, where a healthy and hearty fan scene has developed. There's a dynamic between the crowd and the golfer: Fans enjoy giving golfers a tough time, and the pros seem to embrace it. That's one particular hole, and it seems that one isolated hole, for a particular event on tour where the players expect a raucous atmosphere, is a fun escape for golfers from the usually quiet galleries.

One could argue Ryder Cup galleries were out of hand at Medinah this year (which could have been fueled by alcohol), but the raw emotion brought out the best out of both sides, too. Look at how Ian Poulter reacted to the crowds all week, and how Bradley seemed to be fueled by the loud galleries.

Related: Myers: Hey golf fans, cut the obnoxious commentary

So should golfers just "suck it up" and take the obnoxious behavior from fans?

As Scott from Delaware eloquently puts on GeoffShackelford.com: "Let's just call this a "minor occupational annoyance" for men whose jobs involve playing a game which 99.9 percent of the golfing population pay large amounts of money to play.

"I am confident these professionals can handle these idiots who choose to yell at tournaments just like I can handle the guy who craps so loud in my office bathroom that I can hear him from 50 feet away while I'm working in my office."

We could've done without the last part, Scott. But we hear ya.

Booing and heckling at team sporting events are common. Fans pay a lot of money to their favorite team to attend games. If they feel the team isn't living up to their end of the bargain, and performing to an inferior standard, they're going to let the team know it.

In a team competition like the Ryder Cup, some see the crowd involvement as a rare emotional element lacking in golf. But when it comes to individual stroke play, if you're yelling for the sake of attention (or throwing a hot dog at a golfer), there seems to be a consensus that there's no place for that in golf.

Just ask Kevin Na, who was heckled at this year's Players Championship. Na struggled to pull the trigger off the tee, which resulted in some fans mocking him in song.

"I deserved it," Na said in May. "I mean, I'm being honest."

But was it fair?

"No," Na continued, "Put an average guy in between those ropes, trust me, they won't pull back [the club]."

Not fair. Not warranted.

—Stephen Hennessey

The latest on golf digest

Golf Instruction
Get Game Ready
These 14 fixes will put you in mid-season form now.
Golf Equipment: What's In My Bag: Nick Watney
What's In My Bag
Nick Watney
America's Toughest Courses
Rankings
America's Toughest Courses
Swing Sequence: Louis Oosthuizen
Swing Sequences
Louis Oosthuizen
. Close

Thank you for signing up for the newsletter.

You will receive your first newsletter soon.
Subscribe to Golf Digest
Golf Digest Perks

Golf Digest Tablet Editions

Subscribe today

Twitter

Golf Equipment: 3Balls.com - New and used golf equipment

Sign-up for Golf Digest's Above The Cut