Golf Digest editors picks

Reaction

Hey, Golf World. You don't get it about the US Open.

Golf World readers took exception to our empathizing with players who struggled with the difficult course set-up at the Olympic Club. It was old-style U.S. Open (as opposed to last year's championship on a soft Congressional), but so what, readers said. That's what we love--not the boring "birdiefests" we witness most weeks. This Florida reader speaks for a lot of you.

Dear Editor: Sometimes it seems that you guys just don't get it. The reason that the pros struggled with the "narrow fairways" at Olympic, is because the "grip it and rip it" mentality doesn't work on tight courses. These younger guys, especially, are honed to take out the driver and so what if it's in another zip code....most of today's tournament courses are set up way to easy for the modern equipment in the hands of experts. Believe it or not, most of us amateurs enjoy seeing these guys struggle once in awhile like we do every round. I loved the Open.....and I haven't watched a minute of that boring Hartford thing this week. 
Bob Brewer, Vero Beach, FL
Our old friend Gene Martineau had a different problem post-Open. His was with the World Ranking.

Dear Editor: How can a player ranked No. 1 in the world continue to be ranked No. 1 despite being 0-for-34 in major championships and missing the cut in the U.S. Open? It really is a travesty to the rankings that a player can be proficient in ordinary tournaments and win a lot of money on not so difficult courses and be considered the best golfer despite not being able to compete on the more difficult venues. 
Gene Martineau Roseville, CA
Gene, we agree that the World Rankings are endlessly baffling. And you are correct to point out that Luke Donald has yet to win a major. However. In 2012 Donald has 1 win, 4 Top Tens, and nearly $3 million in earnings. As for "difficult" venues, he was 6th at the Players, 12th at the Memorial, and, okay, only average (T32) at the Masters. In 2011, Donald tied for 4th at the Masters, tied for 7th at the Memorial, tied for 2nd at the Bridgestone Invitational on a tough Firestone course, was 4th at the BMW Championship, T8 at the PGA Championship,  and T3 at the Tour Championship at Eastlake.  No major wins, you're right.  But some awfully good golf over a long period of time. Hence, his ranking. And, as reader Brewer points out, he wasn't the only one to struggle on those "narrow" Olympic fairways. 

 --Bob Carney

The latest on golf digest

Golf Instruction
Get Game Ready
These 14 fixes will put you in mid-season form now.
Golf Equipment: What's In My Bag: Nick Watney
What's In My Bag
Nick Watney
America's Toughest Courses
Rankings
America's Toughest Courses
Swing Sequence: Louis Oosthuizen
Swing Sequences
Louis Oosthuizen
. Close

Thank you for signing up for the newsletter.

You will receive your first newsletter soon.
Subscribe to Golf Digest
Golf Digest Perks

Golf Digest Tablet Editions

Subscribe today

Twitter

Golf Equipment: 3Balls.com - New and used golf equipment

Sign-up for Golf Digest's Above The Cut