Editor's Blog

Results for March 2010 Back to Editors' Blog Index

How to fix golf, part 1

It's pretty well agreed that over two couple of decades we've built too many courses, certainly too many high-end courses, and haven't done enough to fill them with golfers, especially golfers that don't look like us. Without debating the merits of that assessment--I know some of you don't buy this whole idea of "growing" the game, I nevertheless recommend this letter to Golf World, because it makes a very interesting suggestion. There was a time then the industry goal was to build "a course a day," too many of them "country club for a day" courses. This reader argues that what we really needed was munis you could play all week, and we can still have them.
Recent Golf World articles on course architecture, ecology and the economy reinforce that there are no easy answers for a flagging industry so super-charged by personalities, profits and brands that it saw no need to plan for the other shoe dropping. How about reviving some of the faded, publically owned gems through an annual "extreme makeover" competition? Industry professionals could "give back" to communities by transforming courses into environmentally appropriate, economically sustainable destination points for everyday golfers offering "good of the game" initiatives, clinics, leagues, outings, and even tour stops. Naive? Maybe. But I'd take the bet that the nexus of America's entrepreneurial know-how, our national tradition of neighbors helping neighbors and a true passion for golf could make it happen.
Patrice Keegan, Dorchester, MA
Interesting idea: Extreme Golf Makeover. Tell us why your course should be the one. Patrice, given the number of architects with more time than projects on their hands these, days, I think you've got something. Now, we need a sponsor.....
--Bob Carney

Everybody apparently doesn't love Raymond

Today's mailbox contains the ideal mix of complaint, question and comment that keeps the Editors' blogger happy. Let's start with this letter from a California man who is leaning "no" on the new Haney Project show on Golf Channel, starring television personality Ray Romano.
Ray Romano, multi-millionaire, flies in to meet Haney in a Learjet, shows up unshaven, needing a haircut, shirt un-tucked, collar wrinkled and unbuttoned. This poor boy act has got to go. The more I look at this jerk the more I am sickened by his lack of respect for the game of golf and Mr. Haney. Typical Hollywood homeless look. Give me Charles B any day. Not everybody loves Raymond.
Robert Bailie, Duarte, CA
No argument, Robert, on the personal grooming, but I'm torn on this dress code issue. The sloppiness bordering on slovenliness of some golfers today is off putting, and yet I want the game to embrace new golfers and, over time, teach them the errors of their ways. Throwing someone off the course because they're wearing cargo shorts, for example, misses the point, because that choice of dress is not, as you suggest about Romano, a lack of respect for the game. It's a clothing style. We're with you on the basics, though. Invest in a razor.
Hello, I am a faithful subscriber that loves your magazine. I am currently searching for the "perfect" set of new irons for me to purchase, and have thoroughly enjoyed reviewing the equipment issue. One question: I am a 10 handicap, but no means a great ball striker. I am wondering why you did not review the Nike VR irons in your equipment issue. Did Nike not participate in the study? I am very interested in the VR full cavity irons, but would love to see your review on them first.
Dave Gardner, Louisville, KY
Dave, we urge you to try any irons you think might help your game. The Hot List covers every set of irons that will be available for purchase in the spring. Nike participated, but those particular irons didn't make the list. We recommend that you start with the irons on the Hot List, especially the game-improvement and super game-improvement offerings, but there's no reason why you shouldn't also try the VRs, if they look good to you. The "prefection" you seek begins with confidence.
I believe those of us who play from the left side are increasing in number due to the availability of quality equipment and the growth of kids hockey programs around the country which encourage a natural approach to shot making. How about moving into the 21st century by changing terminology to “front foot/back foot” - “top hand/bottom hand” from the traditional right/left used in instructional articles for the past sixty years? Minimal impact to right handers and appreciated by southpaws.
Dave Stimpson, Jacksonville, Florida
You are right, sir! No reason we can't use front/back rather than left/right. It's been our intention to do so, but we sometimes fall back into old habits. Apologies.
--Bob Carney

Your comments on Tiger, Merullo, the game...

Though the Tiger mail has subsided dramatically--I get the impression most of you are bored out of your skulls with scandal--there are a few good ones, presented here. We've also got more mail on Roland Merullo's moving piece in Golf World. Somehow makes sense to juxtapose them.
Interesting how Eldrick has done what only he could do....open our eyes! There are so many exceptional golfers on tour that deserve recognition yet do not receive it because the golf media insists on focusing on TW, whether he is playing or not, whether he is in contention or not. Granted, he is the best golfer in the world and, as such, commands attention. But golf is so much more than that! Those of us who play the game, love the game and respect the game, deserve to see more than idol worship by those who cover the game. Look a little deeper!! The majestic game of golf has so much more to offer!!!
Peter Lartonoix, St. Louis, MO
Our eyes might have also been opened to we golfers' precious way of describing golf's "majesty." How about that old saw "You can tell a man's character by how he plays the game?" Tiger suggests that you can tell no such thing; you can tell how a man plays golf by how he plays golf, is what you can tell. Had lunch yesterday with a good friend who disagrees with me on this--she says she never liked Tiger because of his demeanor on the course--but maybe one positive to Tiger's downfall is that we'll all be a little less haughty about our character-revealing sport.
Many years ago, we were in Boston Garden to see the Globetrotters who were in town and playing a game against the Washington Generals before a Celtics game. Bill Russell came through the lobby on his way to the dressing room. I tried to shake his hand but he just brushed by me and kept moving. I said to him " If you were five feet nine inches nobody would care who you were." He stopped and turned around, stared at me for a few seconds and turned and went where he was going. It was fortunate for me that I was with 5 other guys two of which were over 6' 5" tall! I can still see Russell's stare and this was over 50 years ago. Later in an interview he gave to somebody Russell said the only thing he "owed" the public was a performance. Everything else was his personal life and the public had no right to even ask him about it. I thought about that in the context of what Tiger Woods is going through. Tiger should just man up and get on with the golf. Of course, Russell made almost zilch in endorsements while in Boston whereas Mr. Woods is down for some 100's of millions. I frankly don't care what Woods does off the course ( I feel for his wife and children ) but I have enjoyed the hell out of him playing golf and I think if he got back to doing that ASAP.
Joseph P. Salvia Jr., Chelmsford MA
I'm old and can't remember whether I told all seven of you this, but when my Dad was a kid he lived near Navin Field, later Tiger Stadium, in Detroit and one day captured a foul ball during a Tigers practice session. He waited until the players filed out and rushed up to Ty Cobb to get his autograph. Cobb grabbed the ball and said: "Where the f.... did you get this, kid?" and walked away with it. My Dad still thought Cobb was a hell of a player, and continued to be a Tigers fan until he died. He just concluded that Cobb was a minor league human being. Speaking of Tigers, human beings, getting old and still loving the game, we've received a number of comments about Roland Merullo's golf and aging column.
Congratulations to Roland Merullo for his great article in the March 22nd issue. He really hit the nail on the head. I got my son interested in this great game I love. As a Pastor he needed to relax somehow, and he got it on the course. We are both very competitive. I was Club Champ at my club 38 years ago and now he beats me regularly and thats the way it should be. I emailed some of my golfing buddies about the story and they were able to read it on the net and really enjoyed it. Again, congratulations on a story that can bring tears.
Bob Kopp, Forty Fort, PA
Lot of tears in golf these days, especially for pastors.
--Bob Carney

What irons to buy?

Taking a break from all things Tiger, let's answer this question from a California reader about new irons. I asked Mike Stachura, Golf Digest's Equipment Editor, to reply. hotlist_equipment_290.jpg
I need a new set of irons and I need your help! I have an average score of 90 but no "official handicap". My swing speed is between 85 to 100mph+. I currently have an imitation set of R7 RAC cavity back taylormade irons that are 6+ years old. I want to shoot in the 80's consistently and hopefully break 80 one day soon. Any suggestions, questions, or feedback?
Ryan Johnson, San Diego
Mike's reply, delivered with his characteristic sensitivity:
An IMITATION set of TaylorMade irons? Did you use imitation money to buy them? Do you drive an imitation Mercedes Benz? Do you own an imitation Golden Retriever? First things first, take those fraudulent irons and burn them. Second, write a letter of apology to TaylorMade at 5545 Fermi Court Carlsbad, CA 92008-7324. Third, take a look at the Hot List to get an idea of what's out there and what's good. Fourth, go find a pro shop that has a quality fitting program and an ample selection. See which of your favorites generally suits your mood and needs and then get fit for shaft flex, lie angle, length and grip size. Fifth, get a few lessons and regular checkups this summer with your local pro. If you're not breaking 80 by the end of the year, it's probably because you need a new driver.
--Bob Carney

On Tiger getting back to golf...

All right, it's easy to make too much of this. But since Tiger's two "coming out" interviews on Sunday, we've received a grand total of five emails from you on the subject. The latest report by an "adult entertainer" claiming to have had yet another affair with the world's No. 1 drew zero comment from you. Not being a person paid to analyze these things, I'd nonetheless interpret your non-reaction this way: You've had it with Tiger the rogue and would like to see Tiger the golfer back again. He will be back, it turns out, in Augusta on Monday, April 5, to answer questions from the press at 2 pm. A sports radio show reported today that one of Tiger's alleged mistresses has suggested that she'll release photos during Masters week. I don't think golfers care anymore. They want to see Tiger back on the back of the New York Post, not the front. They want to see him play golf. Meanwhile, what you have written us about was Roland Merullo's thoughtful piece in Golf Worldon golf an mortality. An excerpt:
If we're not there already, someday all of us will be saying, "I used to be able to." We might not wear the bottoms of our trousers rolled, but we'll have more trouble tying our shoelaces, and we will certainly feel a little sting of sadness at the sight of a tee ball that seems to head south almost as soon as it started heading north. What to do about all this is one of the great eternal questions brought up by the great game. Say "yes" to it, the Zen masters would advise. Play in the rain sometimes. Maybe introduce a child, grandchild or younger friend to golf and siphon some enjoyment out of their pleasure. In the end, we can soften the blow, but we can't dodge it.
One reader made something of Merullo's New England's roots:
I am so pleased that Roland Merullo is a contributing columnist to Golf World. His piece on the game of golf and the realities of mortality in the March 22nd issue ranks right up there with the golfing works of the late John Updike and the late Herbert Warren Wind. Merullo grew up in Revere, MA, Updike lived and golfed in Wenham, MA, and Herbert Warren Wind spent his days in Brockton, MA. Clearly, short golf seasons and long winters produced outstanding writers! I may be wrong but another excellent writer and Golf World contributor, John Feinstein, lived in Southern Maine, a stone's throw from the literary triumvirate from Massachusetts!
Daniel McCarron Wakefield, MA
Good letter, Daniel. You remind us of that Herbert Warren Wind quote about golf (or life or Tiger, for that matter): In golf, as in no other sport, your principal opponent is youself.
--Bob Carney

Three takes on Tiger talking again

These three letters to Golf World all arrived this morning, hours after Tiger Woods' first two interviews since the event on Thanksgiving evening. It may be coincidence, but none is sympathetic. images-7.jpeg
Questions that need to be answered: Why give these interviews on the same day as the conclusion of a PGA Tour event and upstage the competition? How angry was Tim Finchem when he found out? The reason for this timeline of events is pure and simple: it was the ultimate power play with Team Tiger sending a message to the lords of golf that Tiger, to steal a line from Reggie Jackson many years ago in describing himself, "is the straw that stirs the drink." Unfortunately Jim Furyk, after being winless for several years, finally gets another one and becomes a mere footnote in the sports press last night and today. Nice way for Tiger and his team to treat a fellow pro. I'm sure this is annoying to a number of players. Tiger could have let Furyk have his moment in the sun and done these interviews outside of the Thursday to Sunday PGA Tour framework. We've waited since Thanksgiving for some comments. We could have waited another day or two. But Team Tiger seems to have an agenda and they don't care how it impacts people. Sorry, Jim. You deserved better.
Sandy Caligiore Lake Placid, NY
I have been a long time supporter and admirer of Tiger Woods, not just for his golfing prowess, but for his professionalism and his class.  I am now very disappointed in him as a man, as a husband, as a father and as a son. He has disappointed and embarrassed just about every person who could possibly be important in his life. The public may restore him to his pedestal once he begins to win again, but his pedestal will forever be just a little shorter than those of Jack Nicklaus, Arnold Palmer, Ben Hogan and Byron Nelson. Tiger may beat all of their records, but he will never stand at the same level as them again.
John Abercrombie Cape Girardeau, MO
The letters last week, before Tiger's interviews with Tom Rinaldi of ESPN and Kelly Tilghman of Golf Channel, weren't much better.
It will be good to see Tiger back on the tour though it's with mixed emotions. As many youth have done, they've (we've) dissed their parents' teachings of life. Now it's not about what he's done but how he responds to what he's done. Augusta will keep out the idiots but something still should be said to express the feelings most have shared. If Tiger is greeted with silence by the gallery the first day, he will get the message. The most powerful expression will be one he has never received. Sort of like his late Dad talking to him. Now if a second coming of Bob May will show up the golf world will see some truly great golf competition. I'd even come in on a sunny day to watch that.
Will Reynolds Issaquah, WA.
The return of Tiger at the Masters is the height of arrogance. To disrupt the greatest tournament of all for the other players is a shame. Can we now call the patrons fans and know that money always wins out over morals. Shame on you, Augusta and Tiger.
Karel Green Boynton Beach, FL
I was away this weekend, playing golf down near Hilton Head. When we weren't on the course, and sometimes when we were, we followed the NCAA tournament games, update by update. Interesting, but few us were rooting for the favorites. We were all pulling for the underdogs--Northern Iowa, Ohio, Cornell, St. Mary's--even when it meant busting up our office-pool brackets. Hard to feel that fervor for the underdogs in golf. People tune in and show up to see the big guns, especially Tiger, play--and win. Could this scandal change that? Judging by your letters, it's put quite a few more fans in the anti-Tiger seats.
--Bob Carney

Golf Saved My Life: Evans Scholars

Max Adler is editing a new reader-contribution column, "Golf Saved My LIfe," and it's generating some interesting mail. Here's one about the April column by reader Keith Anderson.
The story about Keith Anderson and the Evans Scholarship warmed my heart. I am an alum of the Evans program (University of Minnesota). The Evans scholarship is a tremendous program and seeing what it did for Keith Anderson confirms that Chick's dream is alive and well. Hopefully, more needy caddies will be aware of this opportunity from you sharing Keith's story.
Ron Weber, Plymouth, MI.
I'm with you, Ron. I'm also an alumnus, as is my brother Tom, and when I hear that caddy programs are on the wane, I don't think loops lost, but scholarships gone wasting. Receiving the Evans Scholarship is an event that saves, changes, re-directs a young person's life. Although best-known in the Midwest, where the Scholars have houses at the Big Ten schools as well as at Marquette, there are also Evans houses at schools as Far West as Colorado and Washington. Western Golf Association, which administers the scholarship, seeks caddy candidates nationwide. Check out the site for requirements and application procedures. It's worth a look. If you're at a club overseeing a caddy program, it's reason alone to keep that program healthy. It could change somebody's life.
--Bob Carney

Tiger's return: "He is golf, he is your boss..."

What do Tiger Woods and the White House health bill plan have in common? They have split our world, and there is no sign of re-union any time soon. Your recent comments about Tiger's absence--and his imminent return at the Masters--encompass the space occupied politically by Nancy Pelosi and Karl Rove: a big space.


100316_tiger_augusta_470.jpg

Your article about Tiger in the April 2010 issue (Mickelson on the cover) was ridiculous. I am cancelling my subscription and will never read or speak of your magazine again. I do not condone what Tiger did,but how can you blame so much on one guy. Bottom line, he is a person who made a huge mistake, but does not deserve your type of unecessary criticism. He may not make it back, but if he does, you and all the others who chose to kick him while he is down, will come running with your greedy hands out. He is golf, he is your boss and he is your world. As Tony Soprano would say, "Golf Digest is DEAD to me".
Dee Diggs, Illinois
Recent issues of Golf World have been a pleasure to read with more focus ongolfers other than Tiger Woods. I've never been a real fan of Tiger's because he seemed to be too "me-focused," placing himself on a pedestal above all the other golfers. The same goes for the TV coverage. We are finally able to see other golfers that are a part of the tournaments and not an overdose of Tiger Woods especially when he is not in the mix of the final outcome. I certainly hope you keep the mix of coverage as it has been in Tiger's absents after his return to tournament play.
Dottie Snyder, Jacksonville, FL
It has been pure joy to watch golf these last few months on television without Tiger Woods on the scene!  I didn't know that there so many "other" golfers playing the game.  I'm sure if he comes back to play the Masters, he will be the only one we see, and we will have to listen to the announcers talk about how good it is to have him back.
Sandi Rettmer, Tracy, MN
Am I the only golf fan who is not enthralled at the prospect of Tiger's return to golf? Because what it will mean for TV coverage will be cameras focusing on Tiger getting out of his car, walking to the range, waiting on the tee, striding down the fairway, pacing around sizing up putts, chatting to Stevie, even scratching his ear, instead of tracking a hundred other excellent professionals who will at that moment be executing shots. I mean golf shots, equally worthy of the true fan's attention.
Tony Percy, Southport, NC
I get it, Percy, but there is one corner of our world where Tiger Woods really is the world: television. And the executives at ESPN and CBS Sports, who will be presenting the Masters, are licking their chops today. Sean McManus at CBS said that this may be the biggest television event since the Obama inauguration. Remember, when everyone was so hopeful? I think our writers and editors, no matter where they stand on Tiger's dalliances, are also excited about his return.
--Bob Carney

Regrets about Tiger

A great deal has been said of late about Tiger Woods, his life, his game and his future. Not too many letters say it as well as this one from a California reader, though.
Knowing how much and how long I have loved the game of golf, many people have flooded my e-mail in-box with jokes, cartoons and amusingly-doctored photos dealing with the Tiger Woods affair(s). After taking a cursory look at a few of them, I haven't even opened the rest...and don't plan to. Here's why... My lifelong interest in golf and the great champions who have played man's oldest game, is as much based on their character off the course as their prowess on. For example, I grew-up with Bobby Jones as my hero for how he led his personal life in spite of his fame for his mind-boggling on-course exploits. Similarly, while always believing Babe Didrikson Zaharias to have been the greatest athlete of the twentieth century, what I admired most about her was the way she demonstrated time and again, by example, just what a woman was capable of in a so-called Man's World... right up to the end of her tragically abbreviated life. Like every other student of the game, I hope to continue being rendered speechless by the unmatched quality of every facet of Tiger's game, the fierceness of his never-say-die competitive spirit, and the trancelike self-discipline he musters and sustains without interruption through seventy-two holes. What's more, I don't question for a moment that he is entitled to a personal life with its byword being the name of his yacht, or rather ship..."Privacy." All of that having been said though, in my opinion, Eldrick Woods may be an on-course Tiger, the likes of which none have come before him, but alas, off it he is no Mr. Nicklaus, Mr. Hogan, Mr. Nelson, Mr. Jones, Mr. Ouimet or Mr. Vardon. Pity.
Stuart Kern, San Pedro, CA
I like the letter because it captures the hangover-like feeling one has as this sordid episode winds back to some kind of normalcy. What we're left with, at the end of all the accusation, titillation, and shock, is the sense of sadness and disappointment that we ever had to learn this about one of our heroes, the sadness Kern expresses in his final word.
--Bob Carney

Hot List: Hybrids question

We've received many questions on the 2010 Hot List, most involving individual requests for club-buying advice. This one on the Hybrids list fell in that category, but gave Golf Digest Equipment Editor Mike Stachura a chance to explain a bit more about the process of creating the Hot List.

201002hot_list_470-1.jpg

Hoping for your opinion. I am looking at hybrid iron sets. Was wondering if the "lesser" companies like Orlimar, Lynx, Hippo etc. can stand up to the "big boys" like Adams, Cleveland, Ping, Wilson (D-FY or even Di-9) etc. ? Is the quality close? I have been playing for about 5 months now and shoot in the low 100's and want to get to the 90's by the end of summer if possible. So am looking for a quality set of irons, preferablly all hybrids, without breaking the bank. Thank You for your help!
Jeff Abbott, Troutdale, OR


Stachura's reply:

First, in each year's Hot List process, we consider the ENTIRE marketplace.
Those products that make the Hot List fundamentally enhance the paradigm of
that particular club category. Those that don't make the Hot List, in the
simplest terms, fail to move the needle in any meaningful way in some or all
of our four Hot List criteria (Performance, Innovation, Look/Sound/Feel,
Demand). In other words, we've evaluated all of these products and they
simply do not measure up.


Why? First, any club that is significantly less expensive than main line
equipment very likely will use cheaper component materials (shaft, grip).
This can be particularly deficient in something like a graphite shaft. In
other words, don't be fooled by a sporty paint job.
Second, most of these lower level entries do not spend the time, money and
manpower to develop an innovative product. There has been little testing
done to ensure performance is superior to past products, and there is little
sense that elements like turf interaction or sound or even consistency of
manufacturing are at the highest levels.


Third, how much exactly would you save by purchasing a low-level product?
You might find a set of Orlimar Spectre hybrid irons for $400, but for $600
you can get a set of Cobra S2 Max irons (Gold, Hot List 2010), or Cleveland
HiBore XLi (Gold, Hot List 2009). For that same $400, you can still find an
Adams a3OS set (Gold, Hot List 2008). That's a significant amount of money,
perhaps, but don't forget that the Cobra, Cleveland and Adams sets have a
trade-in value, while the Orlimar Spectre's trade-in value on the PGA.com
Value Guide is exactly $0.00.


Finally, I'm not saying that you can't enjoy yourself to a sufficient degree
by opting for an off-brand. Instead, what we do with the Hot List is
determine the products that are superior across our four criteria. If that's
not important to you, and if price is the only thing that matters, then you
may choose to go another direction. Golf Digest, however, is only
recommending the clubs that appear on the Hot List.


Thanks, Rob and Mike.

--Bob Carney

The latest on golf digest

Close

Thank you for signing up for the Tip of the Week newsletter.

You will receive your first newsletter soon.
Subscribe to Golf Digest
Golf Digest Tablet Editions

Twitter

Your Instagram Golf Photos
Subscribe today

Golf Digest Rewards

Golf Equipment: 3Balls.com - New and used golf equipment

Sign-up for Golf Digest's Above The Cut