Cup Consolidation

Is one cup a year too much? Just wait until Tiger or Phil decides to skip one of these extravaganzas

Phil Michelson

Phil thinks golf in the Olympics is a good idea. What's his record on good ideas lately?

By Jim Moriarty
Photo By AP September 5, 2008

A lot of people, including Phil Mickelson, think adding golf to the Olympics is a dandy idea. And it may well be, though the recent history of Phil's dandy ideas bearing fruit isn't all that impressive. Certainly, the addition of the backing of scores of Olympic committees the world over has done wonders for the growth and popularity of badminton, handball, curling and shooting a rifle whilst wearing skis and gloves. Imagine what a few more poor, corrupt officials could do for the game of golf.

On the other hand, maybe we should have our own Olympics every year instead of once every four. The whisper is the Americans are growing golf weary fighting on two fronts, taking on the Europeans in the Ryder Cup one season, then bouncing back the next year to take the measure of the Internationals. The rumors grow with each passing engagement that one of these fine days a Mickelson or a Tiger Woods will no longer want to donate a week of their lives to team-room table tennis only to be harangued with questions afterward about how pitifully they played or how little they care. Could they really be anxious to add the Olympics, too?

If the object is to grow the game worldwide, here's a wildly improbable suggestion: merge the Ryder Cup and Presidents Cup. Let's say the Americans play the Europeans this year, with the Internationals waiting in the wings, waiting to ambush the winner next year in, say, Australia, Canada, South Africa, Korea or even China. In this round-robin scenario, the team that loses cools its heels for a year and comes back in two years, on its own turf, re-charged and ready to take the crown.

The logistics would be difficult but not insurmountable. The side that is sitting out would have two years to arrange a site. The order of host courses in any hemisphere could be determined years in advance by selecting a rota and ticking them off as they're needed.

Naturally, when the Internationals are playing the Europeans, the interest in America would wane. What's so unusual about that? When the New England Patriots play the New York Giants in the Super Bowl, San Diego Chargers fans aren't that interested, either. It doesn't mean San Diegans don't climb down off their surf boards long enough to go to a Super Bowl party and watch the commercials on a flat-screen TV, however. One might suggest the Internationals, as a group, lack the kind of "us versus them" intensity that Europe and America have, for better or worse, engendered. On the other hand, think a few ex-colonies around the globe wouldn't mind having a go at Great Britain, France and Spain? The whole thing could well grow in stature.

The biggest drawback, of course, is money. What are the chances certain unnamed governing bodies would be interested in carving up the fatted calf the Ryder Cup has become? The Sunnis, Shiites and Kurds have a better chance of splitting Iraqi oil revenues. But imagine the worldwide marketing opportunities these matches would provide. If your motivation is to grow the game around the globe, wouldn't it make sense to do it through the associations that teach it and play it? It makes at least as much sense as creating golf's version of the Jamaican bobsled team.

November 21, 2009

Dave Anderson
Dave Anderson
John Shippen becomes a PGA member at last
Jaime Diaz
Jaime Diaz
The life-long struggle of the late George Archer
Tim Rosaforte
Tim Rosaforte
No comeback player of the year for Woods
Matt Ginella
Matt Ginella
USGA is encouraged by visit to Erin Hills
Ron Sirak
Ron Sirak
A year-round schedule is not what's best for golf

Latest Issue

Golf World November 9, 2009
Nov. 9, 2009
China ready for WGC event, Whan named new LPGA commissioner, Cook and Roberts winners on Champions Tour, Grillroom, Tour Talk, Equipment
CLICK FOR PAST ISSUES
Golf World college polls
Stay up to date this season with the Golf World college polls:
The Latest Men's Poll
The Latest Women's Poll
College Players of the Week

2009 MAJORS

Golf: PGA Championship Coverage
British Open Coverage
U.S. Open 2009
Golf: Masters coverage
Readers' Choice Awards

NEWSLETTERS

Golf World's newsletter
Golf Digest's newsletter
Subscribe today

Golf World

Subscribe >

Golf Digest

Visit Subscribe
2010 Pegboards
Give a Subscription to Golf World magazine as a Gift

Best Places to Play — Course Finder

Advertiser Events & Promotions

clubfitting
What equipment have you recently been fitted for: