The Rules Are The Rules

"But it was an honest mistake. I don't know why or how it happened. But, you know, I just forgot to sign it. It was really unfortunate, but hopefully it won't happen again. It was a good learning experience."

To those who decry the disqualification of Wie there is this one last point to make: While perhaps too much is made of it at times-?cheating undoubtedly has occurred-?golf is the only sport where players turn themselves in. Creamer once disqualified herself for a rules violation--the day after the tournament ended when she realized she had violated the rules.

What happened to Wie was unfortunate, and it was sad given how much she has struggled over the last two years. But it was within the rules under which all of the players compete. Golf is different than other sports. The only person who really knows what happened is the player. That's a responsibility each player has to take seriously, and one that must be cherished. It's a big part of what makes golf the game it is: A test not just of skill, but also of character.

If Manny Ramirez hits a home run and the umpire incorrectly says it was a foul ball Ramirez has no opportunity to correct the mistake. Golfers have that right, and with the right comes certain responsibility. Is it really too much to ask of a player that they verify and sign their scorecard? Hey, maybe we should just give them all putts inside the leather.

November 21, 2009

Dave Anderson
Dave Anderson
John Shippen becomes a PGA member at last
Jaime Diaz
Jaime Diaz
The life-long struggle of the late George Archer
Tim Rosaforte
Tim Rosaforte
No comeback player of the year for Woods
Matt Ginella
Matt Ginella
USGA is encouraged by visit to Erin Hills
Ron Sirak
Ron Sirak
A year-round schedule is not what's best for golf

Latest Issue

Golf World November 9, 2009
Nov. 9, 2009
China ready for WGC event, Whan named new LPGA commissioner, Cook and Roberts winners on Champions Tour, Grillroom, Tour Talk, Equipment
CLICK FOR PAST ISSUES
Golf World college polls
Stay up to date this season with the Golf World college polls:
The Latest Men's Poll
The Latest Women's Poll
College Players of the Week

2009 MAJORS

Golf: PGA Championship Coverage
British Open Coverage
U.S. Open 2009
Golf: Masters coverage
Readers' Choice Awards

NEWSLETTERS

Golf World's newsletter
Golf Digest's newsletter
Subscribe today

Golf World

Subscribe >

Golf Digest

Visit Subscribe
2010 Pegboards
Give a Subscription to Golf World magazine as a Gift

Best Places to Play — Course Finder

Advertiser Events & Promotions

clubfitting
What equipment have you recently been fitted for: