Second-Guessing

Justin Rose

Justin Rose found himself in a bind at No. 17 last year. Photo: Andrew Redington/Getty Images

Several players acknowledge the impact on the 14th, a bunkerless, uphill par 4 with a steeply pitched fairway that sends many drives into the right rough. Geoff Ogilvy says a second-cut lie there forces the run-up approach "that Bobby Jones intended" and is a shot today's players aren't comfortable playing.

Former U.S. Open and PGA champion David Graham has spent 15 years on the Masters Cup and Tee Marker Placement Committee and sees the second cut making its impact best felt under firm conditions.

"If you put the player on the fairway in firm conditions, he is more likely to execute with more confidence knowing that he's going to make better contact with the ball," Graham says. "If the greens are soft, then I'm not really sure anyone has a plus or minus advantage from the secondary cut."

For every example of increased difficulty, players can point to the rough's helping hand. Raymond Floyd, who won the 1976 Masters, thinks the taller grass is saving many players "from making double and triple bogeys," singling out the par-5 second hole where hooked drives are less likely to reach a little-known creek down the left side.

Sandy Lyle feels the second cut has improved several holes for the player "by giving us more grass under the ball." He cites the shade-prone seventh as well as the area of rough now sitting between the edge of the 13th fairway and the tributary of Rae's Creek. "The thin lies sometimes made it very hard to get clean contact. Now the ball sits up better," Lyle says.

And what about the man who has won three of his four Masters since the addition of the longer grass?

"I think it would play harder now if they took away the second cut," says Tiger Woods. "I'm sure it would be a more interesting test."

Woods is convinced that pulled tee shots on the first two holes are prime examples of Augusta National simplified.

"Now they get held up by the rough -- I'm sorry, second cut."

At least he knows what to call it.

November 22, 2009

Dave Anderson
Dave Anderson
John Shippen becomes a PGA member at last
Jaime Diaz
Jaime Diaz
The life-long struggle of the late George Archer
Tim Rosaforte
Tim Rosaforte
No comeback player of the year for Woods
Matt Ginella
Matt Ginella
USGA is encouraged by visit to Erin Hills
Ron Sirak
Ron Sirak
A year-round schedule is not what's best for golf

Latest Issue

Golf World November 9, 2009
Nov. 9, 2009
China ready for WGC event, Whan named new LPGA commissioner, Cook and Roberts winners on Champions Tour, Grillroom, Tour Talk, Equipment
CLICK FOR PAST ISSUES
Golf World college polls
Stay up to date this season with the Golf World college polls:
The Latest Men's Poll
The Latest Women's Poll
College Players of the Week

2009 MAJORS

Golf: PGA Championship Coverage
British Open Coverage
U.S. Open 2009
Golf: Masters coverage
Readers' Choice Awards

NEWSLETTERS

Golf World's newsletter
Golf Digest's newsletter
Subscribe today

Golf World

Subscribe >

Golf Digest

Visit Subscribe
2010 Pegboards
Give a Subscription to Golf World magazine as a Gift

Best Places to Play — Course Finder

Advertiser Events & Promotions

clubfitting
What equipment have you recently been fitted for: