Golf Digest editors picks
Ron Sirak

Wait Just A Second!

Before you get too excited about Tiger Woods' latest win, remember the biggest questions remain unanswered

March 12, 2013

The thing about bandwagons is that they are moving targets. Jumping on and off comes with its share of risk. Right now, the Tiger Woods bandwagon, light of load in recent years, is once again buckling under the weight of its cargo.

When a guy has won five of his last 19 tournaments and happens to have 76 PGA Tour victories and 14 major championships, there is every reason to say he is the best player in the game. But saying Woods is the best right now -- which he may well be despite his No. 2 ranking -- and saying he has returned to his former greatness are two very different things.

And before you jump down to the comments section and start calling me a hater, please consider this: Tiger Light is good enough to be better than anyone else playing. That's how much talent this guy has. At a diminished level he is still better than just about anyone else. All I'm saying is that Tiger is not the same player he once was, but neither is Kobe Bryant and he's still pretty good.

Why do I think we should look at the run of success Woods is on with a wee bit of caution? Two things: The way he has closed out his victories and his recent performances in the major championships. His record in both areas raises some interesting questions.

Podcast: Paul Azinger on what went right for Tiger at Doral

So far this year, Woods has won the Farmers Insurance Open by four strokes, taking it for the seventh time, and the WGC-Cadillac Championship by two. But at Torrey Pines, he played the last five holes four over par. And at Doral, he bogeyed two of the last three holes and was about a yard away from spinning the ball off the final green and into the water.

Those were not the slam-the-door-in-your face kind of finishes we were used to seeing from Woods when he was establishing his reputation as the best closer this side of Mariano Rivera. Yes, he won and yes, he hit some sensational shots, but that brings us to point No. 2.

The bar for achievement set by Woods himself has always been the record 18 major championship victories held by Jack Nicklaus and not the mark of 82 PGA Tours wins set by Sam Snead. Right now, I'd say it's a sure thing that Tiger breaks the Snead record. But I still think the Nicklaus mark is going to be a tough get.

Last year, Woods won the Arnold Palmer Invitational for the seventh time and the cry was that he was back. Then, in the next tournament he played, Tiger finished T-40 in the Masters with rounds of 72-74 on the weekend.

In May of 2012, Tiger captured the Memorial for the fifth time, then in the next tournament he played, he finished T-21 in the U.S. Open with rounds of 75-73 on the weekend.

Then in July, Woods took home the title at the AT&T National. The next week he missed the cut at the Greenbrier Classic and while Woods finished T-3 at the British Open two weeks later, he closed a pedestrian 70-73.

When Woods shot 74-72 on the weekend at the PGA Championship to finish T-11, it meant he had failed to break 70 in any of his eight weekend rounds at the majors in 2012 and had a stroke average for those closing two rounds of 72.87. Those are not Tiger numbers.

That's why I am still watching the Tiger bandwagon pass and not jumping on. And make no mistake about it -- watching is fun. The guy hits some remarkable shots. Those closing hiccups at Torrey and Doral and the weekend record in the majors makes me now leap on another bandwagon often inspired by Tiger: hyperbole.

Around The Web
Subscribe to Golf Digest

Subscribe today