The race for PGA Tour Player of the Year is the most compelling I can recall. Some believe it
should be Tiger Woods, who dominated the first half of the year and had that electrifying
victory at the U.S. Open. Others say Padraig Harrington is more deserving. He won the British
Open and PGA Championship and had four other top-five finishes.
My choice is Padraig. His two majors surpass Tiger's one major and three other tour victories.
I don't think even Tiger would dispute that Padraig's second half of the season was better
than Tiger's first half. A vote for Tiger is essentially saying that had there been no knee
injury he would have won one of the majors that Padraig did. But there is no assurance that
Tiger would have won the British or PGA, and you can't give him credit for winning majors he
didn't play.
There's a precedent for my thinking. In 1974, I won eight PGA Tour events and the Dunlop
Phoenix in Japan. Gary Player won two majors and seven tournaments outside the United States.
They gave player of the year to me, but if I had been voting, I would have gone with Gary.