Bomb & Gouge Blog

The Weak are Inheriting the Earth

BOMB: Well, after spending 8-plus hours with you in a car driving back from Toronto, some of the thoughts are starting to come to the surface. Chief among them is this: Last week saw K.J. Choi using a putter grip about the size of a soda can, Colin Montgomerie using a belly putter and those two plus Brad Bryant all using 60-degrees wedges. We hear lots of people bellyaching that shotmaking is being taken out of the game but they have little problem allowing a putter grip that Choi himself said, “reduces the movement of your wrist.” It’s the golf equivalent of this. And anyone using a belly putter might to grab hold of one of these for comfort, too. And would Choi have made that miracle bunker shot on 17 if it were a 56-degree instead of a 60-degree? Doubt it. I used to be OK with the long putters and the like, but there’s just something not right about these. Of course, watching you three-putt from eight feet the other day, perhaps you’ve changed your position on crutches such as these.

GOUGE: Not at all. More crutches for everyone. Why not set up some netting along the right side of every fairway so those wild heel slices are gently pushed back into play? Why not allow players two or three throws a round (depending on what USGA testing suggests would be most equitable)? Why not let them use some sort of catapult to launch tee shots? I know we harped on the unnecessary clamor over equipment regulation the other day, but sometimes you have to look at technology’s progression objectively. We’re both more than OK with a steady generalized growth over time, but when there are weird affected departures, it’s time to make it just stop, especially when that kind of development is fueled by a desire to compensate for some staggering ineptitude or lack of intestinal fortitude. Bracing the grip end of the club to your gut is not in the best interests of the game and shows an inherent psychological weakness in the individual. Exposing weakness is the whole point of the golf exercise. Holding on to a putter grip about the size of a racing bratwurst is not the stuff of unwavering mental strength. Using a pancake flipper as a greenside chipping club is using technology to overcome a lack of skill. None of us would be the worse for wear without any of these so-called innovations. Or maybe we just need a few more out there. Maybe what everyone needs isn’t a 60-degree wedge. What we need is a 73-degree wedge. Because, after all, a 70-degree just isn’t enough club to let you hit all the shots you need. All I know is I can skull that club across the green, too.

Categories:

Comments

Archived Comments (4) Click to expand

Are you sure you guys didn't get some bad maple syrup up there? These rants almost sound like they belong on _another_ blog...

While I don't have any problem with what you guys are suggesting (outlawing belly putters, the 60-degree, etc.), as you think about it it really underscores the difficulty of the USGA/R&A's task in regulating equipment. To wit: wasn't it Billy Casper who anchored the putter handle to the inside of his thigh? It was a normal putter in other ways (in contrast to the bellies), why can't he hold it the way he wants? Is it _that_ weird? Aren't the burlesque, "secret handshake" putting grips of DiMarco et al sort of crutch-like, too? Seeing someone hold a putter with one hand upside down is almost revolting--like that guy your magazine photo'd several years ago who tried to make full swings with his left hand turned upside down on the club (thumb pointing up).

I'm glad I don't have to make the equipment decisions.

Maybe Frank Thomas is right after all. We could kill several birds with one stone by lowering the club limit to 10.

Posted by 86general July 16, 2007 5:58 AM

I think you guys got some bad maple syrup up there.

Of course you're right--you can go off the deep end with anything, and I'd agree that if we're going to say 'no,' I'd rather see it be something like a belly putter or a 60-degree wedge, rather than an easier-to-hit driver. But doesn't this all just underscore how hard equipment regulation really is? Didn't Billy Casper anchor the putter against his thigh? Who's gonna say something bad about Billy? What about the "secret water-buffalo lodge handshake" putting grips of DiMarco, O'Meara, Kite, et al?

Maybe Frank Thomas had it right--10 clubs, and that's it. It would save us all some money and lighten the load.

Posted by 86general July 16, 2007 6:02 AM

I think you guys got some bad maple syrup up there.

Of course you're right--you can go off the deep end with anything, and I'd agree that if we're going to say 'no,' I'd rather see it be something like a belly putter or a 60-degree wedge, rather than an easier-to-hit driver. But doesn't this all just underscore how hard equipment regulation really is? Didn't Billy Casper anchor the putter against his thigh? Who's gonna say something bad about Billy? What about the "secret water-buffalo lodge handshake" putting grips of DiMarco, O'Meara, Kite, et al?

Maybe Frank Thomas had it right--10 clubs, and that's it. It would save us all some money and lighten the load.

Posted by 86general July 16, 2007 6:04 AM

Why do you two argue against a 60-degree wedge while being just fine with a 56-degree version? Most of the guys I know carry a 60-degree, and if you forced me to choose between them then I'd take the 56-degree out of my bag instead. (I carry four wedges: 48, 52, 56, and 60.)

Maybe we ought to limit the loft on drivers while we're at it.

This seems totally out of whack with where you guys typically come from. Lob wedges have been around for at least 15 years (I think Tom Kite was the first Tour player to use one on a regular basis), and I see no reason to bad mouth them.

GOUGE responds: Dear Rocket Scientist: 60 degrees of loft is more than 56 degrees of loft. Get it? Why not force the best players to hit greenside wedge shots with less loft? Tom Watson doesn't carry a 60-degree wedge and he chipped in at Pebble Beach to win. This would be a change that again, by the way, would have no impact on average golfers. Probably would force them to get a little better with their short games. Again, it's another mistake the USGA made in the era of the 1980s and 1990s. For some reason, that group did not have the ability to envision a future that was as obvious as a
And your idea about limiting driver loft is wonderful, too. Nothing less than 11 degrees of loft, how about that? Let's see you optimize launch conditions with 120 mile clubhead speed with one of those senior citizen lofts.

Posted by BobbyJohn July 21, 2007 5:37 PM
Post A Comment

Equipment Videos

Subscribe today
Subscribe today