No. 5--The Quarry and The Legend at Giants Ridge in Biwabik, Minn. ($89). I’m grouping them together because if you were willing to get to Biwabik, which is practically in Canada, you’d never play just one. I prefer The Legend (opened in 1997, ranked No. 72 on our list of America’s 100 Greatest Public), over The Quarry (opened in 2003, ranked No. 20), but it's splitting rocks because they’re both good and they’re both a bargain. Two different looks, The Legend (pictured above) runs along a river and a lake and sits at the base of what functions as a ski resort most of the year. When it opened, my colleague, Ron Whitten, wrote a review of the Quarry: “Hands down, the finest course in Minnesota. It’s a combination of Pebble Beach, Pine Valley, Merion and Tobacco Road, with a bit of architectural Tabasco sauce sprinkled in for the occasional jolt.” That might be a bit of literary hot sauce, but you get the idea. (Twilight, $60, start time varies. Replay rate is $58.)No. 4--The Olympic Course at Gold Mountain Golf Club in Bremerton, Wash. ($76, includes a cart). Washington golf isn’t all Chambers Bay. When I was in town to scout the future Open venue, I was told I had to get to Gold Mountain, which is covered in trees. And now I’m passing on the tip. The Olympic course hosted the 2006 U.S. Amateur Public Links Championship and it will host the 2011 U.S. Junior Amateur. The cold, wet weather is obviously a factor, but I love the deal they’re running until March: Pay $100 and get 30 days of unlimited golf. (Twilight, $27, starts at 3 p.m.)
No. 3--Black Forest at Wilderness Valley in Gaylord, Mich. ($75). Tom Doak has built only two public courses in his home state of Michigan. He told me Black Forest is where he was experimenting with a lot of bunkering techniques that he still uses today, and that if he had to do it all over again, he’d make this course more playable for the masses. It’s tough, but far from unfair. The blue tees (6,496 yards) have a slope of 143. The slope from the white tees (6,129 yards) drops to 127. I played a combination of both tees and had all I could handle. One of Doak’s favorite holes is the 10th, and it’s my favorite as well. It’s a long and narrow par 5--tunneling ants have had more room to work. (Twilight, $50, starts at 3 p.m.)
No. 2--Wailua Municipal Golf Course on Kauai, Hawaii ($70). The Bethpage Black of Hawaii, Wailua has hosted three U.S. Amateur Public Links Championships. The first nine was built in the 1930’s; the second nine was added in 1961. It’s only three miles from the Lihue airport, so it’s an easy stop on your way to or from the North Shore. It has several holes running along the water, including my favorite, the “signature” 173-yard 17th. You will not be run over with polish--if there’s a dress code, they don’t enforce it--but you might be run over by the pace of the locals, so I suggest you keep up with the group in front of you. (Twilight, $30, starts at 3 p.m., and it’s first come, first serve.)
No. 1--Coronado Municipal Golf Course in Coronado, Calif. ($35). If Bethpage Black is my favorite course near my favorite city in the country, Coronado (pictured below) is my favorite course near San Diego, my second favorite city. The last time I played there was with my brother and a best friend from high school. Most of my brother’s clubs ended up in the neighboring San Diego Bay (I think he kept his driver and his putter). It was quite a scene at a course known for its high quality and a low fee. Advanced tee times (8-14 days) are $60. All other tee times can be obtained through a daily lottery and phone calls. (Twilight, $15, starts at 1 p.m. in the winter.)
So there you have it, my list of top 25 public courses, and a list of top 10 based on value. Any other lists you're looking for? I'm taking requests.If you want a useful link, click here for the list of America's 100 Greatest, re-ranked by price.
--Matty G.




I'll post my top 5 on Friday . . .
No. 1--Bethpage State Park (Black) in Farmingdale, N.Y. ($54 for state residents, $120 for everyone else). The positive: It’s everything that’s right in an overbuilt, overpriced and overprivatized industry. As the world of golf makes layered adjustments, I hope for a future of more parks with multiple golf courses that cater to state-residents, but don’t gouge the out-of-towners. The Black is my favorite, not just because of the way the golf course builds with a steady stream of intensity, climaxing first at holes 10 through 12, and then again at 15 through 17, but I also appreciate the following: it’s always in great condition, it’s walking only, the extra space built in between tee times, you don’t see any houses throughout the course and it’s void of typical pretentiousness at a place with a rich history. The lineage of design goes back to A.W. Tillinghast (some say Joe Burbeck). Regardless, we owe a degree of gratitude to the USGA for putting the spotlight back on blue-collar golf when it rediscovered the Black in 2002. The negative: Trying to get a tee time (the price you pay for affordable and accessible). I suggest trying mid-week afternoons during shoulder seasons. A lot of people criticize the 18th hole (pictured above) for being a weak finish, but I'm OK with it. After holes 15 through 17, I'm grateful for a short par 4. Favorite hole: No. 15, because it reminds me I have a lot of work to do before I can consider myself a real golfer.
No. 6--Whistling Straits Golf Club (Straits) in Sheboygan, WI. ($340). The positive: I’m giving Pete Dye one in my top 10, and my guess is, it will forever be the Straits course (I think I've seen the best U.S.-based courses he has to offer.) Yes, it’s too much course for me, but I caught it in calm conditions and I flirted with a great score, relatively speaking. Unlike the Ocean Course at Kiawah, you feel like Dye took into account the potential for wind (and the amateur golfer) when he built Whistling Straits. It’s another spiritual spot where you look around a lot and remind yourself: life is short so you might as well enjoy it. The negative: It’s expensive, but it is one of the premiere Big League Ballparks in the country. The fifth hole is an odd fit. The four par 3s are spectacular, but they teeter on being repetitive. Favorite hole: No. 17, a par 3 (pictured above).
No. 11--Sea Island Resort (Seaside) on St. Simons Island, GA. ($295). The positive: The official term is a redesign, but I still say this is my favorite Tom Fazio design (he basically started from scratch). To have one of the “best golf resorts in the country,” you have to have a great golf option. Seaside (pictured above) rings that bell for Sea Island. It’s an easy walk in a sweet setting, steeped in the ceiling of southern hospitality. The Lodge is the second best mancation destination in the country (behind Bandon Dunes). The negative: The whole place is pricey, but as a result of the owner's financial struggles (and the economy), the resort should get more affordable and more accessible. Favorite hole: No. 4.
No. 16--Dunes Golf & Beach Club in Myrtle Beach, S.C. ($200). The positive: Widely considered the best of The Grand Strand (until Caledonia came along). With about 100 courses available to the public in that area, that puts it in the top 2 percent of a golf mecca. It drips history (pictured above) and it has been the lead sled dog of drawing golfers to Myrtle Beach since 1949. The negative: It caters to members. In my Away Game I dinged it for their service to the general public; hopefully they took it as constructive criticism. Favorite hole: No. 4
Tim Finchem, The Commissioner of The Real Tour, has been clear: The Show must go on. But what have commissioners of fantasy golf leagues decided to do about a Tigerless tour?
On my recent flight from LA to NYC, I sat next to Jets QB Mark Sanchez (see post below), I had in-flight wireless and I made a minor contribution to Unicef, the global organization dedicated to helping children in all facets of life, most notably, life itself.



