Deeds and Weeds

Results in Economy Back to Deeds and Weeds Index

The "Instability" of Colorado Golf Club

Anybody who watched the Senior PGA Championship on TV last weekend had to be impressed with Colorado GC, the Bill Coore/Ben Crenshaw course outside Denver making its debut as a major championship site. Like just about every course that duo designs, the course looked natural, quirky, challenging and fun to play.

Can you sense the "but" coming?

Turns out Colorado GC is in a bit of a tight spot, financially -- which really shouldn't be a big surprise, considering it opened three years ago, just about the time the recession wave began to break over golf's shoreline. In his report from the Senior PGA in this week's issue of Golf World, senior editor Bill Fields talked to Mike McGetrick, founding owner of the upscale private club, who denied rumors the club would close after the tournament.

"No, we're not [closing]," McGetrick told Fields. "We hope in the next 90 days to be recapitalized, and that things are going to be great. We have 308 members, and Colorado GC is going to be here, whether I own it or somebody else does."

In a wrapup story published Tuesday, the Denver Post touched on the "instability" of Colorado GC, and floated the idea that the PGA of America might buy the club in an arrangement similar to its ownership of Kentucky's Valhalla GC. But McGetrick and PGA of America CEO Joe Steranka, while admitting a possible sale has been discussed, didn't sound optimistic that it would happen.

"The talks were never serious, in part because of the uncertainty of what's going on here," Steranka told the Post. "Valhalla is still a Kentucky-run private club; while the PGA owns it, we're very hands-off in the management. In my mind, corporate-run clubs lose their individuality, the personal culture."

You can read the entire Denver Post story here.

-- G.R.

'The last good year in the golf business was 2001'

The Legends of Indiana Golf Course, a "highly regarded" upscale 36-hole public facility in suburban Indianapolis, situated next door to the headquarters of the Indiana PGA Section and the Indiana Golf Association, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection this week. 

The filing had little in the way of details, with Legend owners claiming debts of between $1 and $10 million, and assets of between $1 and $10 million. Legends general manager Ted Bishop told The Indianapolis Star "It would be business as usual for our customers" while the facility restructures its finances.

You can read The Indianapolis Star story here.

It's a familiar story to anyone who has been following the golf course industry, public or private, the last two years or so. But this sentiment from Ron West, who operates four courses in the Indianapolis area and is a past president of the Indiana Golf Course Owners Association, was rather stark:

"I traveled the state a lot [during 2007 and 2008] and I bet in 2008 that 50 percent [of public courses] were on the verge of foreclosure. The last good year we had in the golf business was 2001, and since that point everybody's seen declines in revenue and rounds. The only courses around making any money all are lucky enough to have no debt service and 10-year-old carts and reasonable maintenance costs."

-- G.R.

Membership Group Buys Stone Eagle

Stone Eagle, in Palm Desert, Calif., has been saved. The details are in this story in The Desert Sun.

The private 18-hole club, featuring the only Tom Doak-designed course in the Palm Springs area, has been shut down for about a month, and in foreclosure since the beginning of the year. But 14 people -- seven couples, six of them members at Stone Eagle -- have bought the club for cash. The story doesn't include a price, but recent reports said a larger group of club members was trying to raise $12 million to buy it.

Stone Eagle opened in 2005. Memberships cost $100,000, and the story claims the club had 190 members at the time of the foreclosure. The new ownership group has made no announcement regarding membership structure in the future. But local officials are just pleased the club has a future.

From the story: "The purchase and reopening of the club provides some much-needed good news for golf courses in the valley, which have been hit with dwindling membership and a drop in players as a result of the recession. 'It's terrific for the whole desert,' said Tom Cullinan, general manager at Stone Eagle. 'Golf is our lifeline.' "

-- G.R.

Cher's Hualalai Home Sells for $8.7 Million

The entertainer Cher sold her house on the golf course of the Hualalai Resort on the Big Island of Hawaii this week, and she didn't do too badly.

The house -- on .75 acres, with 8,800 square feet, six bedrooms and a view of the Jack Nicklaus designed layout (which is hosting this week's Champions Tour event, the Mitsubishi Electric Championship) and the Pacific Ocean -- sold for $8.7 million. Reports had it valued at between $8 and $12 million.

The Honolulu Advertiser has the story here.

-- G.R.

Golf Houses For $100 Million

Now this was kind of a fun article, even if it has no basis in reality -- at least not my own. TheStreet.com, using figures provided by the real estate website Zillow.com, has a list of homes in the U.S. for sale for the staggering price of $75 million and up.

Two of them have a golf connection. 

The first is "Tranquility," a 10,000 square-foot on 210 acres near California's Lake Tahoe. Built by Joel Horowitz, "one of the co-founders of Tommy Hilfiger," the house has a staircase modeled after one that was on the Titanic, a cigar lounge inspired by one at New York's St. Regis Hotel and -- outside -- a two-hole golf course. Asking price: $100 million.

The second is Albemarle House in Charlottesville, Va. The house has 45 rooms and more than 25,000 square feet, and it is the centerpiece of a 300-acre property with three ponds, guest cottages and -- ta-da -- an 18-hole golf course designed by Arnold Palmer. The catch is that the course hasn't actually been built yet, which -- in our opinion -- makes the $100 million price tag seem a little steep.

-- G.R.

Byron Nelson Championship Site Faces Foreclosure

The Four Seasons Resort and Club Dallas at Las Colinas -- better known to this audience as the home of the PGA Tour's HP Byron Nelson Championship -- was the subject of a foreclosure filing today in Dallas.

According to reports, the facility's creditor, U.S. Bank NA, "is seeking repayment of a $183 million loan on the property" from the resort's owner, Los Angeles-based BentleyForbes, "and has scheduled a forced sale on Feb. 2."

The Dallas Morning News called the foreclosure filing "the largest in North Texas in more than 20 years." The newspaper's story on the filing is here. The Dallas Business Journal's report is here.

Of course -- as in many foreclosure and bankruptcy proceedings -- three words are being used to describe the activity at the facility in question: business as usual.

"We do not expect any change in our day-to-day operations or services," Las Colinas Four Seasons general manager Michael Newcombe told the Dallas Morning News. "We are proud of the nearly $60 million in improvements that our owners have made to our property over the past two years."

-- G.R.

Arizona Update: 'Getting Hit From All Sides'

The Arizona Republic starts the new year with an update on the overall golf market in Phoenix and the surrounding suburbs. In summary: golf course owners and developers aren't noticing any rebound, at least not yet. Some, uh, highlights:

Many private clubs have opened their courses to the public, even for just one or two days a week, in an effort to increase rounds and revenue.

Many facilities are negotiating green fees. One golfer talks about having played the Arizona Biltmore for $55, and guesses it would have cost him twice that much a year ago.

Arizona officials estimate that "only" 5 percent of the state's approximately 340 golf facilities are in dire economic condition, compared to 15 percent nationally.

The story said there were no golf course residential developments opened in Arizona in 2009 -- startling news (economic troubles notwithstanding) considering how "white hot" the state's golf market was as recently as five years ago.

You can read the complete story here.

-- G.R.


Country Club of South Sells For $11.1 million

An update to the Jan. 4 post on the Country Club of the South: the suburban Atlanta club, which recently went into foreclosure, was sold Tuesday at auction for $11.1 million. The new owner is the Bank of North Georgia, located in Alpharetta.

News of the sale was reported by the Atlanta Business Journal. As we noted previously, the sale involved only the golf club and its facilities (including its Jack Nicklaus designed golf course). The 700 private homes that make up Country Club of the South were not part of the foreclosure or the sale.

-- G.R.


Grenelefe Back on the Market

Florida's Grenelefe Golf & Tennis Resort, once the crown jewel of the Tampa market but now fallen on hard times due to the struggling real estate market and damages inflicted by Hurricane Charley in 2004, is for sale. Details in this article in the Tampa Bay Business Journal.

Grenelefe is currently owned by Westgate Resorts, one of the biggest companies in the time-share industry, which bought it at foreclosure five years ago. A recent deal to sell the property for $50 million fell through, and according to the story, Westgate doesn't expect to fetch anywhere near that amount this time.

"They're looking for fair market price," a real estate analyst told Tampa Bay Business Journal.

-- G.R.

'People Are Cutting Golf Out of Their Diets"

Roger Vincent had a story in Sunday's Los Angeles Times about the difficult state of the golf course and golf real estate business in this country. Having read a similar version of this story more than once in the last 12 months, I would say there wasn't a lot that was new here, other than an update on where we are with course closures in the U.S. in 2009 (114 through September, according to Vincent and the National Golf Foundation, offset by 44 course openings).

Still, it's a worthwhile read, since it pulls together all of the relevant statistics and details about the struggling golf business, as well as focuses specifically on the Southern California market. Imagine, for instance, being able to buy a Los Angeles area country club of $6.5 million (as Vincent reports of Chevy Chase CC in Glendale)? You couldn't get a bathroom in Malibu so cheap...

-- G.R.
Close

Thank you for signing up for the Tip of the Week newsletter.

You will receive your first newsletter soon.
Subscribe to Golf Digest
Subscribe today