architecture

Worst of the best

The not-so-great holes on America's 100 Greatest  

Worst of the best

Illustration By Chris Gash

December 2008

Just as Cindy Crawford has the mole and Robert Redford those baggy eyes no amount of surgery can remedy, the most glamorous golf courses in America have flaws, too. No course is perfect, not even those ranked on Golf Digest's list of America's 100 Greatest. Sometimes the flaw is a substandard hole, the result of an architectural hiccup or a committee compromise or a ham-handed alteration by a design dilettante. Hadn't noticed? That's because you were blinded by the marquee. Here are Architecture Editor Ron Whitten's picks of the worst holes on the nation's best courses.


THE BOTTOM 10
2007 rank on 100 Greatest in ( )

Bandon Dunes
1

Bandon Dunes (31)

Bandon, Ore. 

Par-5 18th / A blind tee shot, a straight, boring fairway and an ugly gray lodge behind the green mar this otherwise extraordinary course.

 
Pebble Beach
2

Cypress Point Club (4)

Pebble Beach 
Par-4 18th / No fairway, just cypress trees practically everywhere.
 
3

Flint Hills National G.C. (49)

Andover, Kan. 
Par-5 18th / An awkward tee shot to a fairway pinched by water left and trees right.
 
Hazeltine National G.C. (89)
4

Hazeltine National G.C. (89)

Chaska, Minn. 
Par-3 17th / A drive-and-pitch par 4 was converted to a 182-yard par 3.
 
5

Medinah C.C. (No. 3) (11)

Medinah, Ill. 
Par-4 ninth / The hole turns left and the fairway slopes right, into trees.
 
Oak Hill C.C. (East) (25)
6

Oak Hill C.C. (East) (25)

Rochester, N.Y.  
Par-3 sixth / The catcher's-mitt green yielded four aces in one round at the 1989 U.S. Open.
 
Photos: Bandon Dunes, J.D. Cuban; Hazeltine National G.C., David Cannon/Getty Images; Oak Hill C.C., Rick Stewart/Getty Images; The Olympic Club, Jamie Squire/Getty Images; Pebble Beach G. Links, Al Bello/Getty Images; Whistling Straits, David Cannon/Getty Images
November 21, 2009

Blogs

Where's Matty G? Blog
On the road with Senior Editor of Travel Matt Ginella
CLICK HERE FOR MORE BLOGS

Golf Digest Ambush

Golf Digest Ambush
You and your golfing buddies could be featured in a future issue of Golf Digest!
WATCH THE LATEST AMBUSH

Course Finder

Places to Play
Search our Best Places to Play directory with detailed course info and reader comments.

Travel Trouble

Travel Trouble
Senior Editor of Travel Matt Ginella addresses your travel questions and woes.

Long Drives

NEWSLETTERS

Golf Digest's newsletter
Golf World's newsletter
Subscribe today

Golf Digest

Subscribe >

America's Greatest Courses

Best new courses of '08

America's Best Resorts

Golf Digest Shop

Golf World

Visit Subscribe
2010 Pegboards
Give a Subscription to Golf Digest magazine as a Gift

Best Places to Play — Course Finder

Advertiser Events & Promotions