The Local Knowlege

News & Tours

Let the word go forth: Best ball isn't the right format for a fundraiser

By Keely Levins

There's a certain mentality that comes with playing a fundraiser tournament. It's relaxed, it's fun, you're probably going to win an ironic prize for something, you're going to spend a good amount of money on raffle tickets, there's often an open bar -- these are all good things.

130918-levins-scramble-480.jpg
What's not a good thing is showing up and having to play your own ball. There's this fundraiser tournament that I've played in for the last few years that's always been a scramble. At least it was until this year, when my foursome showed up and organizers had decided to "shake things up" and make it a best ball. This, I soon learned, was a mistake. Here's why scrambles are always better in these sort of outings:
 
There's more room for higher handicappers in scrambles
If you're a high handicap player, team fundraiser events are a perfect opportunity to play with friends who are good players. It's fun to play your buddy's ball out of the middle of the fairway. You're also not obsolete because there's the chance you'll stick a wedge or drop a putt. If nothing else, you can putt first and give your teammates a read on the line. You don't have that opportunity in best ball. If you're out of the hole, you're out of the hole and there's nothing you can do about it.

 
Better players can take more chances
If you're a good player, these tournaments are an opportunity to finally not play your own ball. You have to do that all the time; this is a low-pressure opportunity to not have to worry about your individual score. There are going to be times when one of your partners puts it in a perfect position off the tee, and you're going to get to take a risk you wouldn't usually consider. Taking risks knowing there's no punishment is fun, and any time you're thinking creatively on the golf course is good for your game.
 
Scrambles teach you to have a short memory
One of the biggest things mental coaches talk about is having a short memory on the golf course: Forget the bad shots, and forget the good ones. Scrambles set you up to think like this. If you snap-hook one OB, it doesn't matter. Someone in your group is going to hit a better shot, and you're going to get to help make birdie from their tee ball. By nature of the format, you forget about your bad shot and become invested in your partners' shots and how you're going to be helpful in the immediate future.
 
Best ball gets too personal
This happens especially in a two-man best ball. It's all fun and games until the better player is out of the hole. Then the less-skilled player has to play well. The pressure usually produces three-putts, or worse. The better player is mad about messing up, and the partner is bummed for not rising to the occasion. There are definitely those days when you and your partner are in sync and picking up each other's slack, but let's be honest, the opposite happens much more often.

 
Going low is fun
You can play your own ball and shoot 90 any day of the week. You're at a fundraiser. You want the judgment-free opportunity to play someone else's ball and shoot 67. 

Subscribe to Golf Digest
Subscribe today